Case of Andrew Goodman
THIS PAGE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION
THIS PAGE IS UNDER CONSTRUCTION
Disclaimer: Inclusion in this website does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement. Individuals must decide for themselves if the resources meet their own personal needs.
Table of Contents:
2010
- 1st case pending against Andrew Goodman 2nd case pending against Andrew Goodman (07/26/2010)
- Former Ohel Employee's Bond Set At $1 Million (11/15/2010)
- Orthodox Sexual Abuse Scandal: 117 kid victims and 85 arrests in Jewish enclave
(12/11/2011) - Haredi sex abuse scandal revealed in NY (12/13/2011)
2011
-
Brooklyn D.A. Investigation Leads to 85 Sexual Predators Arrested in Orthodox Jewish Community (12/11/2011)
- Brooklyn Man Accused of Sexually Abusing Orthodox Boys In 144-Count Indictment (12/12/2011)
- Child sex abuse scandal rocks Orthodox Jewish community after 85 arrested
(12/12/2011) - Orthodox Child Sex Abuse Details Revealed: Report (12/11/2011)
- B'klyn perv in Orthodox sex abuse case takes judge's sweetheart deal (06/22/2012)
- Confessed pervert tells stunned Brooklyn courtroom he loves his victim (07/12/2012)
- B'klyn perv only gets 2 years behind bars after molesting boy for years (07/12/2012)
- How Did Brooklyn Perv Andrew Goodman Get Off With A 2-Year Prison Sentence? Seriously...How? (07/13/2012)
- Community outraged: Brooklyn pedophile who 'loves' his victim gets only 2 years (07/13/2012)
- Light sentence for convicted molester is a perversion of justice (07/14/2012)
-
Brooklyn D.A. Mum On Slap-On-The-Wrist Plea Deal For Convicted Pervert Andrew Goodman (07/17/2012)
- FBI Press Release (07/25/2012)
- Andrew Goodman, Perv Who Got Smooch-On-The-Wrist Plea Deal, Could Be Federally F**ked (07/25/2012)
- Convicted molester may face life (07/25/2012)
- B'klyn perv could be locked up for life (07/25/2012)
- Finally a hero to protect the kids (07/26/2012)
- Pedophile victim faces abuser in court a second time, after state judge gave monster only two-year sentence (10/10/2012)
- Brave teenager comes face to face with abuser in court after judge gave moleser two-yar sentence (10/11/2012)
____________________________________________________________________________________
1st case pending against Andrew Goodman
Case #: 2010KN044615 PL 260.10 01
**TOP CHARGE**
A Misdemeanor, 1 count, Arrest charge, Arraignment charge
Description: Act Manr Injur Child < 17 PL 240.26 03 Violation, 1 count, Not an arrest charge, Arraignment charge
Description: Harassment 2nd
____________________________________________________________________________________
2nd case pending against Andrew Goodman
Case #: 05592-2010
Charge Detail Disposition/Sentence PL 130.45 01
**TOP CHARGE**
D Felony, 23 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Indictment Count: 117
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 130.55 00 B Misdemeanor, 26 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Sexual Abuse 3rd
Indictment Count: 125
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 130.55 00 B Misdemeanor, 26 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Sexual Abuse 3rd
Indictment Count: 131
Date Added: 07/26/2010 PL 130.55 00 B Misdemeanor, 26 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description:
Sexual Abuse 3rd
Indictment Count: 133
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 130.55 00 B Misdemeanor, 26 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Sexual Abuse 3rd
Indictment Count: 137
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 260.10 01 A Misdemeanor, 7 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Act Manr Injur Child < 17
Indictment Count: 139
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 260.10 01 A Misdemeanor, 7 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Act Manr Injur Child < 17
Indictment Count: 142
Date Added: 07/26/2010
PL 260.10 01 A Misdemeanor, 7 counts, Not an arrest charge, Not an arraignment charge
Description: Act Manr Injur Child < 17 Indictment Count: 144
Date Added: 07/26/2010 ____________________________________________________________________________________
Former Ohel Employee's Bond Set At $1 Million
By Shmyra Rosenberg
Failed Messiah - September 15, 2010
Goodman's bond was set this morning at $1,000,000.
I'm told Ohel fired Goodman when he was arrested.
Mark Meyer Appel brought people to the court this morning to support Goodman's alleged victims.
____________________________________________________________________________________
New York Post - December 11, 2011
SNARED: Andrew Goodman (to the left), one of 85 sex-abuse
suspects arrested over the last three years by Project Kol Tzedek, has
been accused of preying on the boys of Brooklyn’s Orthodox Jewish
community and — even after his arrest on sex-assault charges — was
caught on video ushering teens into his Flatbush home (below). He is
being held on Rikers Island in lieu of a $1 million cash bail.
Evidence
seized in Goodman’s room included lubricants, empty liquor bottles,
boys’ clothing with DNA samples, and a butcher knife.
By Lilit Wagner
YNet News - December 13, 2011
It happened for a very long time: Eighty-five men from Brooklyn's ultra-Orthodox community are suspected of sexually abusing more than 100 of the community's children and teenagers.
Many, including the victims' parents, allegedly knew about it but chose to keep silent – until one of the community organizations decided to reveal the horrible secret and went to the police.
The affair was reported by the New York Post on Sunday. The New York police are still unsure when the abuse began, but it clearly stretched over several years. Several years of suffering, trauma and perhaps the worst thing of all – a conspiracy of silence aimed at preventing humiliation and shame, all at the expense of the helpless children.
An initiative called Kol Tzedek (“voice of justice") decided to expose the dreadful acts, and as the months went by more and more men were arrested. The organization members located children who fell victim to the abuse and convinced them to complain.
The case involves 117 victims – 89 of whom are under the age of 17. The number of arrests is expected to increase as the affair unfolds.
So far, 38 indictments have been filed and 14 of the detainees have already been sent to jail for up to 20 years for rape, sodomy and kidnapping. Another 24 suspects have been released on bail, and the rest are still being questioned.
According to the investigation, in some of the cases parents knew their children were being molested but gave in to community pressure and chose to remain silent.
Goodman was already arrested in 2010, but was released on bail. The price of his freedom appears to have been heavy: Since returning home, he hosted dozens of children and allegedly abused them during parties with liquor and child porn. Some of the kids were photographed by neighbors entering and leaving the apartment.
So far, authorities have charged him with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush — one from age 11 to 15, the other from age 13 to 16.
According to the 144-count indictment, which alleges numerous violations since 2006, Goodman filmed sex acts with the youngsters on a Web cam. Court papers and source say he also “threatened the life” of a boy who reported him to authorities.
“Andrew Goodman is known in our community as a lifelong molester who preys on young boys and ruins their lives,” a Talmudic scholar at Congregation Bais Torah wrote to Brooklyn Judge Martin Murphy, who is hearing the case, the New York Post reported.
Rabbi Shea Hecht, of the Hasidic Lubavitch group, accused Goodman on a Jewish radio show of "hunting" for prey.
He said Goodman went to yeshiva playgrounds, once offering a reward for any boy who found his “lost glasses". Goodman also pressured boys to recruit others, the rabbi said.
Goodman is currently in detention and has pleaded not guilty. “These were not forceful —no one was held against their will," he lawyer said, adding that the alleged victims were “troubled kids who did not have a good home life.” He claimed that one had boy ran away and Goodman “gave him a safe haven."
According to the newspaper, Goodman studied in a yeshiva in Israel several years ago and "stopped being religious" in recent years.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Brooklyn D.A. Investigation Leads to 85 Sexual Predators Arrested in Orthodox Jewish Community
By Andre Tartar
New York Magazine - December 11, 2011
Brooklyn Man Accused Of Sexually Abusing Orthodox Boys In 144-Count Indictment
By Shmyra Rosenberg
Failed Messiah - September 15, 2010
Goodman's bond was set this morning at $1,000,000.
I'm told Ohel fired Goodman when he was arrested.
Mark Meyer Appel brought people to the court this morning to support Goodman's alleged victims.
 |
| This is, I'm told, a picture of Andrew Goodman –– Shmyra Rosenberg |
____________________________________________________________________________________
Orthodox Sexual Abuse Scandal: 117 kid victims and 85 arrests in Jewish enclave
By Susan EdelmanNew York Post - December 11, 2011
He looks like a movie star, but many members of Brooklyn’s Jewish community believe he is a monster.
Andrew
Goodman, 27, who worked for Jewish social-service agencies, is charged
with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush — one from
age 11 to 15, the other from age 13 to 16.
Goodman filmed sex
acts with the youngsters on a Web cam, according to the 144-count
indictment, which alleges numerous violations since 2006. He has pleaded
not guilty.
The handsome Goodman, who held parties in his home
with liquor and child porn, also “threatened the life” of a boy who
reported him to authorities, court papers and sources say.
SNARED:Andrew Goodman (above), one of 85 sex-abuse
suspects arrested over the last three years by Project Kol Tzedek, has
been accused of preying on the boys of Brooklyn’s Orthodox Jewish
community and — even after his arrest on sex-assault charges — was
caught on video ushering teens into his Flatbush home (below). He is
being held on Rikers Island in lieu of a $1 million cash bail.
He’s one of an astounding 85 accused Orthodox child molesters that
Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes’ office says it has busted in
the past three years in an initiative called Kol Tzedek, Hebrew for
“voice of justice.”
The cases involve 117 victims — a number that has the community reeling from the extent of the horrors of pedophilia.
Launched amid complaints that Hynes was soft on Orthodox child
predators, Kol Tzedek aims to coax victims to come forward, despite
strong pressure in the insular religious community to cover up such
crimes.
All but two of the suspects are men, and more than half
the victims are male, said Assistant DA Rhonnie Jaus, chief of the sex
abuse and crimes against children division.
Of the 38 cases closed
so far, 14 perps got jail time, ranging from a month to 10-to-20 years
for crimes that included sex abuse, attempted kidnapping, and sodomy,
Jaus said.
The other 24 have walked free. They got probation,
pleaded to minor charges, or saw their cases dismissed — often because
victims or their parents backed out under community pressure.
Agudath
Israel of America, a prominent body of Torah sages, requires anyone
alleging sex abuse by a fellow observant Jew to first report to its
rabbis, who decide whether the case should go to secular authorities.
Goodman’s
case, which Hynes’ office hasn’t publicized, shows how the community’s
response has started to change. Rather than keeping it among the
Orthodox, some alleged victims turned to sympathetic religious leaders
and outside authorities to help lock up a menace.
“Andrew Goodman
is known in our community as a lifelong molester who preys on young boys
and ruins their lives,” a Talmudic scholar at Congregation Bais Torah
wrote to Brooklyn Judge Martin Murphy, who is hearing the case.
Neighbors were shocked when Goodman, freed on $10,000 bail after his
arrest in July 2010, still had boys sneaking into his 15th Street home,
where he lives with his parents and sister, in the middle of the night.
Community
members made a chilling surveillance videotape that officials said
shows teens, ages 15 or 16, entering and leaving the house between 3
a.m. and 5:30 a.m.
Goodman is seen opening his front door for the boys — four on one August night and three on another.
In
one image, two men, including an officer of Shomrim, a volunteer
patrol, apparently argue with Goodman at the front steps. Goodman goes
inside and ushers a boy out of his house.
When told of the tape at Goodman’s September 2010 arraignment, Judge
Patricia DiMango raised Goodman’s bail to an unusually steep $1 million,
cash only. He remains at Rikers Island pending a Dec. 21 hearing.
Goodman’s
lawyer, Izzy Fried, indicated his client would fight the charges,
telling DiMango, “These were not forceful — no one was held against
their will.”
The judge countered that “anyone with a child” would
agree that an 11-year-old “is not capable of making these types of
decisions.”
Fried told The Post the alleged victims are “troubled
kids who did not have a good home life.” One boy ran away, and Goodman
“gave him a safe haven,” the lawyer said.
He called the accusation that Goodman threatened the boy “baloney.”
Goodman, he confirmed, once turned to his young accuser in court and mouthed, “I love you.”
In
court papers obtained by The Post, the boy’s pediatrician said the
sustained sexual and emotional trauma had “robbed him of his youth.”
The
child suffers symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder and
depression. Once “vibrant and energetic,” the doctor said, “that boy is
no more.” The abuse “destroyed him.”
Goodman was adopted and grew
up in a traditional Jewish family. His parents went to synagogue and had
Friday-night Sabbath meals, sources said. Goodman attended yeshivas
through high school and went to yeshivas in Israel, the last time in
2005.
He used to wear a yarmulke, a source said, but in recent years “stopped being religious.”
Rabbi
Shea Hecht, of the Hasidic Lubavitch group, said one of Goodman’s
alleged victims came to him and bared his anguish. Hecht, who helps
Hynes’ office with community relations, urged the boy to go to cops.
“You know I’m going to end up dead,” Hecht said the terrified teen told him.
Hecht, on a Jewish radio show, accused Goodman of “hunting” for prey.
Goodman
went to yeshiva playgrounds, once offering a reward for any boy who
found his “lost glasses,” Hecht said. Goodman also pressured boys to
recruit others, the rabbi said.
He allegedly took one boy to
Atlantic City for a weekend, a source said. He allegedly plied boys with
liquor and pills and showed porn on his laptop.
Hecht said he contacted the parents of several boys in the surveillance video, but they refused to cooperate.
Goodman,
a paralegal in a law office, worked weekends for OHEL, a prominent
nonprofit that serves at-risk kids and disabled adults.
OHEL is one of several agencies affiliated with Hynes’ Kol Tzedek program.
For
11 months, starting in June 2009, he took a minimum-wage job as a
caregiver in a group home for physically and mentally disabled adults,
18 and up. His tasks included helping residents go to the bathroom,
change clothes and shower, officials said.
OHEL fired Goodman days
after his arrest, said spokesman Andrew Moesel. It hired a psychologist
to interview residents and “determined that no OHEL client had in any
way been harmed.”
Goodman also worked in a group home for disabled adults run by the Women's League Community Residences, another Jewish charity.
Hynes spokesman Jerry Schmetterer said Goodman is not charged with abuse at the nonprofits.
Brooklyn
District Attorney Charles Hynes’ Project Kol Tzedek, Hebrew for “voice
of justice,” aims to coax ultra-Orthodox Jews to report childhood sexual
abuse despite community pressure to stay silent. After three years, the
DA reports these results:
- 85 accused predators arrested since January 2009, two female
- 117 victims: 89 under age 17, the rest up to age 23, when the statute of limitations expires
- 47 cases pending; 38 closed
- 14 offenders sentenced to jail, from a month to 10-to-20 years
- 24 free—on probation, after pleading to lesser charges or after caseswere dismissed
____________________________________________________________________________________
Haredi sex abuse scandal revealed in NYBy Lilit Wagner
YNet News - December 13, 2011
It happened for a very long time: Eighty-five men from Brooklyn's ultra-Orthodox community are suspected of sexually abusing more than 100 of the community's children and teenagers.
Many, including the victims' parents, allegedly knew about it but chose to keep silent – until one of the community organizations decided to reveal the horrible secret and went to the police.
The affair was reported by the New York Post on Sunday. The New York police are still unsure when the abuse began, but it clearly stretched over several years. Several years of suffering, trauma and perhaps the worst thing of all – a conspiracy of silence aimed at preventing humiliation and shame, all at the expense of the helpless children.
An initiative called Kol Tzedek (“voice of justice") decided to expose the dreadful acts, and as the months went by more and more men were arrested. The organization members located children who fell victim to the abuse and convinced them to complain.
The case involves 117 victims – 89 of whom are under the age of 17. The number of arrests is expected to increase as the affair unfolds.
So far, 38 indictments have been filed and 14 of the detainees have already been sent to jail for up to 20 years for rape, sodomy and kidnapping. Another 24 suspects have been released on bail, and the rest are still being questioned.
According to the investigation, in some of the cases parents knew their children were being molested but gave in to community pressure and chose to remain silent.
'Victims were troubled kids'
One of the suspects is Andrew Goodman, 27, who worked for Jewish social-service agencies and looks like a movie star. According to the New York Post, many members of Brooklyn’s Jewish community believe he is a monster.Goodman was already arrested in 2010, but was released on bail. The price of his freedom appears to have been heavy: Since returning home, he hosted dozens of children and allegedly abused them during parties with liquor and child porn. Some of the kids were photographed by neighbors entering and leaving the apartment.
So far, authorities have charged him with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush — one from age 11 to 15, the other from age 13 to 16.
According to the 144-count indictment, which alleges numerous violations since 2006, Goodman filmed sex acts with the youngsters on a Web cam. Court papers and source say he also “threatened the life” of a boy who reported him to authorities.
“Andrew Goodman is known in our community as a lifelong molester who preys on young boys and ruins their lives,” a Talmudic scholar at Congregation Bais Torah wrote to Brooklyn Judge Martin Murphy, who is hearing the case, the New York Post reported.
Rabbi Shea Hecht, of the Hasidic Lubavitch group, accused Goodman on a Jewish radio show of "hunting" for prey.
He said Goodman went to yeshiva playgrounds, once offering a reward for any boy who found his “lost glasses". Goodman also pressured boys to recruit others, the rabbi said.
Goodman is currently in detention and has pleaded not guilty. “These were not forceful —no one was held against their will," he lawyer said, adding that the alleged victims were “troubled kids who did not have a good home life.” He claimed that one had boy ran away and Goodman “gave him a safe haven."
According to the newspaper, Goodman studied in a yeshiva in Israel several years ago and "stopped being religious" in recent years.
____________________________________________________________________________________
By Andre Tartar
New York Magazine - December 11, 2011
Earlier this summer, the Hasidic community in Borough Park was ripped
asunder by one of the most gruesome murders imaginable — a young Jewish
boy smothered and disemboweled. The murderer may have been a troubled
outcast, as Matthew Shaer describes in last week's New York,
but he was still one of their own — a chilling reality check. Now, the
Brooklyn District Attorney's office has revealed the results of a
three-year investigation into sexual abuse in the borough's Orthodox
Jewish community that is downright seismic: 85 sexual predators arrested
and 117 victims identified, according to the Post.
Front and center in the investigation, it seems, is one Andrew
Goodman, a 27-year-old adopted as a child into an Orthodox Jewish
family, who had spent the past several years working with nonprofits for
at-risk youths and mentally disabled adults, where his responsibilities
included helping residents go to the bathroom and shower. He faces a
144-count indictment stemming from two victims in Flatbush — next door
to Borough Park — who claim to have been sexually abused by Goodman
during their early teens. But the number of his victims is likely much
higher. After being released on bail in summer of 2010, following his
arrest, the community was witness, either via videotape or visit from
the Shromrim patrol, to three separate occasions when Goodman had young
boys in his house (where he lives with his mother and sister): four the
first time, three the second, and one the third.
So far, about 38 cases in the Brooklyn D.A.'s Project Kol Tzedek — which the Post translates as Hebrew for "voice of justice" (find a tip sheet with helpline information here) — have been closed, with just under two thirds resulting in the perps walking free. Many pleaded to lesser changes, with the Post claiming
that some got off mostly scot-free because "victims or their parents
backed out under community pressure." Of the fourteen or so who were
handed jail sentences, the longest sentence may be up to twenty years.
While difficult days of introspection are surely ahead for Brooklyn's
insular Orthodox enclaves, growing awareness of such crimes and rabbis'
willingness to seek out secular help are essential for the community to
protect its most vulnerable even while preserving its oldest and most
cherished traditions.
____________________________________________________________________________________
CBS NEWS-NY - December 12, 2011
The latest one, uncovered by the Brooklyn District Attorney, accuses a man of preying on young boys.
It’s one of the latest cases to rock the Orthodox community. Andrew Goodman, a 27-year-old from Midwood, is charged with with 144 counts of sexual abuse of two boys.
It’s charged that since 2006, Goodman, who worked for Jewish social
service agencies, sexually abused one boy aged 11 to 15, and another,
age 13 to 16, while recording the activity on a webcam.
“I spoke to the two boys. They are 100 percent credible,” said Rabbi
Shea Hecht with the National Committee for Furtherance of Jewish
Education.
Hecht said one of the two alleged victims is especially credible.
“He remembered everything — dates, times,” Hecht told CBS 2′s John Slattery.
Goodman lives on East 15th Street, where community members say they
shot a video of teens, entering and leaving his home during early hours.
“To say that these kids spent an exorbitant amount of time with him
does not in and of itself mean that crimes were committed,” Goodman’s
attorney, Israel Fried, said.
Fried said the only evidence he knows of is the word of the kids.
“There are inconsistencies — meaning that it’s not a slam dunk,” he said.
The DA’s office said in the last three years 85 accused Orthodox
child molesters have been charged involving 117 victims — 38 cases have
been resolved with 14 convictions.
“When that person is arrested for doing it to one victim or to two
victims, I guarantee there are 10, 20, 30 victims somewhere out there in
the community,” Assemblyman Dov Hikind said.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Child sex abuse scandal rocks Orthodox Jewish community after 85 arrested
Daily Mail - December 12, 2012
117 alleged victims spoke out from tight-knit religious society
An Orthodox Jewish community has had to face up to claims of child sex abuse after 83 men and two women were arrested.
An initiative was set up to encourage victims to come forward despite pressure from the close-knit religious society to hush up the crimes.
Some 117 male and female victims have approached authorities in Brooklyn, New York since 2006. There were 89 accusers under the age of 17.
According to the New York Post, one suspect Andrew Goodman, 27, worked with Jewish charities involving vulnerable young people and the disabled.
He was charged with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys at his home in the Flatbush neighbourhood last September.
One child was abused between the ages of 11 and 15, the other from 13 until he was 16 years old.
Goodman reportedly filmed sex acts with the boys on a webcam after plying them with alcohol in his bedroom and making them watch child porn.
Neighbours had filmed Goodman sneaking the children into the home he shared with his parents and sister between 3am and 5.30am.
In the surveillance tape, Goodman was seen opening his front door for the boys, according to the Post.
Lubricants, empty liquor bottles, boys’ clothing and a butcher knife were discovered in the 27-year-old's room.
Goodman’s lawyer Izzy Fried told the New York Post that the alleged victims were 'troubled kids' and his client had provided them with a 'safe haven'.
He also threatened the life of one boy who reported him to authorities, it has been claimed. Goodman has pleaded not guilty.
He is being held at Rikers Island Prison until his next hearing on December 21.
After being shown the footage in court last September, Judge Patricia DiMango set the suspected paedophile's bail at $1million.
Brooklyn District Attorney's office had been accused of being soft on child abusers which lead to steps being put in place to make it easier for suspected victims to come forward.
The plan was called Kol Tzedek which translates from Hebrew as 'voice of justice'.
DA Charles Hynes instigated the outreach programme which offers a confidential hotline and access to 'culturally sensitive' social workers from the sex crimes bureau.
Assistant DA Rhonnie Jaus, head of the child sex abuse division, said 38 individuals had been prosecuted so far with 14 abusers jailed.
Sentences varied from one month to 20 years for crimes including sex abuse, attempted kidnapping and sodomy.
However 24 alleged paedophiles were not jailed. In some instances, the case against them collapsed when victims and their families backed out of giving evidence in court following pressure from the religious community, according to the assistant DA.
Authorities have another 47 cases pending.
The Orthodox Jewish organisation Agudath Israel of America, which has its headquarters in Manhattan, rules that anyone who claims to have been sexually abused by another Jew must consult rabbis first.
Only then is the decision made whether to go to secular authorities.
Goodman worked for OHEL Children's Home and Family Services which provides care for vulnerable children and disabled adults. The non-profit group aims to help victims who have suffered domestic, sexual or emotional abuse.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Forward - June 12, 2012
Brooklyn prosecutors say authorities have arrested 85 people in the Orthodox Jewish community on child sex abuse charges in the past three years, the New York Post reported Sunday, confirming earlier reports in the Forward.
Prosecutors in the office of Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes told the Post that 38 of the sex cases had been closed so far, with 14 convictions. The suspects got jail time ranging from a month to up to 20 years for crimes that included sex abuse, attempted kidnapping, and sodomy, the paper said.
Twenty-four suspects were freed after the cases against them fell apart, the report said.
The rest of the cases are still pending under a controversial program called Kol Tzedek, or Voice of Justice, which aims to coax victims in the insular community to come forward about abuse.
The paper cited Assistant D.A. Rhonnie Jaus, chief of the sex crimes bureau. The Forward requested an interview with Jaus several weeks ago. That request was declined.
Hynes’s office did not immediately respond for a request for comment Sunday.
Among those accused is Andrew Goodman, 27, who worked for Ohel and other Jewish social-service agencies. The Post says he is charged with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush, and filming sex acts dating back to 2006, according to the 144-count indictment, which alleges numerous violations since 2006.
Goodman has pleaded not guilty.
The Forward first broke the news weeks ago that nearly 90 Orthodox men had been arrested on child abuse charges. At that time, prosecutors refused to furnish any additional information about the cases, but suggested they would do so by the end of November.
Among the cases reported by the Forward was that of Boro Park Rabbi Baruch Lebovits, who was sentenced last year to up to 32 years in prison after being convicted of sex abuse.
Victims’ rights advocates hailed it as a turning point in the battle against sexual abuse in the insular Orthodox community. But Lebovits is now free on bail and his conviction is now unraveling amid allegations of perjury, conspiracy and extortion.
Just last week, Hynes’ spokesman Jerry Schmetterer refused to return calls from the Forward asking for more information about the cases.
____________________________________________________________________________________
B'klyn perv in Orthodox sex abuse case takes judge's sweetheart deal
By Jose Martinez
New York Post - June 22, 2012
A pervert who sexually abused two Orthodox Jewish brothers accepted a judge's sweetheart deal today that will spring him from jail in September - over the furious objections of Brooklyn prosecutors.
Andrew Goodman pleaded guilty to 48 felonies - including criminal sex acts with a minor, sex abuse and sexual misconduct - after Justice Martin Murphy dangled a 2-year sentence in front of him.
Assistant District Attorney Kevin O'Donnell said prosecutors would have pursued a penalty that could have locked up Goodman for "dozens, if not hundreds of years."
"The people are of the opinion that this is a very lenient offer to
the defendant and one that's going to put him in a position to act on
his fantasies and abuse more children when he gets out of jail,"
O'Donnell said.
"All right," Murphy said.
Goodman, who was arrested in June 2010 for preying on the boys over several years, was thrilled with the offer.
"It's an amazing deal," said Israel Fried, a defense lawyer for Goodman. "He's very happy to put this behind him, do his time and hopefully get on with his life.
"He was never looking to not take responsibility."
Community members had filmed Goodman sneaking 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home during pre-dawn hours, and trashed him as a "lifelong molestor who preys on young boys" in letters written to the judge.
Fried said prosecutors "weren't going to offer anything," charging they weren't going to go easy on Goodman because of the heavy criticism District Attorney Charles Hynes has taken for his handling of sex-abuse cases in Brooklyn's Orthodox Jewish community.
"These are the crimes de jour, so to speak and they're the ones that have put the District Attorney under the microscope," Fried said. "That's why they've taken such a hard line."
But Hynes fired back that prosecutors should "have the right to appeal a disposition taken over their objections."
"Here, an acting State Supreme Court Justice promised a sentence of two years to someone who pled guilty to 48 felonies," he said in a statement.
Goodman is the adopted son of a Jewish family and attended yeshivas in Israel through 2005.
He previously studied at a community college and did volunteer work with developmentally disabled adults.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Confessed pervert tells stunned Brooklyn courtroom he loves his victim
An admitted child molester stared at his teenage victim and professed his unending love for him Thursday in front of a shocked Brooklyn courtroom — but still got only two years behind bars.
The sickening display by Andrew Goodman, 27, came after one of his two victims begged Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy not to go so easy on the serial pedophile, who'll be back on the streets in two months after time served. Prosecutors also strongly objected to the plea agreement.
“Letting this man go is a very grave mistake," the boy, now 17, said as his body trembled. “I have no doubt he'll try to do the same thing to other children once he gets out."
Goodman admitted to sexually abusing the youth and his brother for four years, starting when they were 12 and 13.
The victim described how his handsome neighbor earned his trust by buying him gifts, taking him to restaurants and alienating him from his parents before pressuring him into having sex.
"You are the worst thing that ever happened to me," he told the defendant. "You are the devil disguised as a human."
When it was Goodman's turn to speak, he turned to the traumatized victim and told him "I love you" as the packed courtroom gasped and grunted in disbelief.
"I did and still do to this day love (you)," the predator added. "I fell in love with you and I wish I never allowed my sexual desires to get in the way of what I valued more, which is your friendship."
None of that — or pleas by the boys' mother and prosecutor Elizabeth Doerfler, who called the sentence "woefully low" — swayed the judge.
“You caused a lot of pain to all the complainants," Judge Murphy told Goodman. "The statements that you made today are ill-advised to say the least."
But without giving an explanation, he meted out the minimum allowable sentence that was agreed to after the former social worker pleaded to the entire 48-count indictment.
Prosecutors were seeking seven years in prison on each count, which would have added up to a de facto life sentence.
Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes said the sentence "defies logic and is frankly inexplicable."
Goodman will likely also have to register as a sex offender for life.
When he made bail after his 2010 arrest, concerned community members surreptitiously filmed numerous other boys leaving his Flatbush home in the early morning hours.
No additional cases emerged, but, after hearing about the surveillance, a different judge locked Goodman up in lieu of $1 million bail, meaning he's already served almost his entire sentence.
The boy described in court “four long and torturous years" in which Goodman groomed him then made him feel "bad and unappreciative" if he didn't succumb to the sexual come-ons.
As a result of the abuse, the teen said, he quit school, has no friends and is struggling to cope in social situations.
"This is a very dangerous man," he told the judge. "Not only because of the crimes he committed, but also because he has no remorse."
The victims' mother and other advocates warned that the lenient penalty will discourage others from going through the hardship of filing complaints. Brooklyn prosecutors have railed against intimidation some accusers face when bringing abuse allegations in the Jewish community.
____________________________________________________________________________________
____________________________________________________________________________________
Child sex abuse scandal rocks Orthodox Jewish community after 85 arrested
Daily Mail - December 12, 2012
117 alleged victims spoke out from tight-knit religious society
An Orthodox Jewish community has had to face up to claims of child sex abuse after 83 men and two women were arrested.
An initiative was set up to encourage victims to come forward despite pressure from the close-knit religious society to hush up the crimes.
Some 117 male and female victims have approached authorities in Brooklyn, New York since 2006. There were 89 accusers under the age of 17.
According to the New York Post, one suspect Andrew Goodman, 27, worked with Jewish charities involving vulnerable young people and the disabled.
He was charged with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys at his home in the Flatbush neighbourhood last September.
One child was abused between the ages of 11 and 15, the other from 13 until he was 16 years old.
Goodman reportedly filmed sex acts with the boys on a webcam after plying them with alcohol in his bedroom and making them watch child porn.
Neighbours had filmed Goodman sneaking the children into the home he shared with his parents and sister between 3am and 5.30am.
In the surveillance tape, Goodman was seen opening his front door for the boys, according to the Post.
Lubricants, empty liquor bottles, boys’ clothing and a butcher knife were discovered in the 27-year-old's room.
Goodman’s lawyer Izzy Fried told the New York Post that the alleged victims were 'troubled kids' and his client had provided them with a 'safe haven'.
He also threatened the life of one boy who reported him to authorities, it has been claimed. Goodman has pleaded not guilty.
He is being held at Rikers Island Prison until his next hearing on December 21.
After being shown the footage in court last September, Judge Patricia DiMango set the suspected paedophile's bail at $1million.
Brooklyn District Attorney's office had been accused of being soft on child abusers which lead to steps being put in place to make it easier for suspected victims to come forward.
The plan was called Kol Tzedek which translates from Hebrew as 'voice of justice'.
DA Charles Hynes instigated the outreach programme which offers a confidential hotline and access to 'culturally sensitive' social workers from the sex crimes bureau.
Assistant DA Rhonnie Jaus, head of the child sex abuse division, said 38 individuals had been prosecuted so far with 14 abusers jailed.
Sentences varied from one month to 20 years for crimes including sex abuse, attempted kidnapping and sodomy.
However 24 alleged paedophiles were not jailed. In some instances, the case against them collapsed when victims and their families backed out of giving evidence in court following pressure from the religious community, according to the assistant DA.
Authorities have another 47 cases pending.
The Orthodox Jewish organisation Agudath Israel of America, which has its headquarters in Manhattan, rules that anyone who claims to have been sexually abused by another Jew must consult rabbis first.
Only then is the decision made whether to go to secular authorities.
Goodman worked for OHEL Children's Home and Family Services which provides care for vulnerable children and disabled adults. The non-profit group aims to help victims who have suffered domestic, sexual or emotional abuse.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Orthodox Child Sex Abuse Details Revealed: Report
Forward - June 12, 2012
Brooklyn prosecutors say authorities have arrested 85 people in the Orthodox Jewish community on child sex abuse charges in the past three years, the New York Post reported Sunday, confirming earlier reports in the Forward.
Prosecutors in the office of Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes told the Post that 38 of the sex cases had been closed so far, with 14 convictions. The suspects got jail time ranging from a month to up to 20 years for crimes that included sex abuse, attempted kidnapping, and sodomy, the paper said.
Twenty-four suspects were freed after the cases against them fell apart, the report said.
The rest of the cases are still pending under a controversial program called Kol Tzedek, or Voice of Justice, which aims to coax victims in the insular community to come forward about abuse.
The paper cited Assistant D.A. Rhonnie Jaus, chief of the sex crimes bureau. The Forward requested an interview with Jaus several weeks ago. That request was declined.
Hynes’s office did not immediately respond for a request for comment Sunday.
Among those accused is Andrew Goodman, 27, who worked for Ohel and other Jewish social-service agencies. The Post says he is charged with sexually abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush, and filming sex acts dating back to 2006, according to the 144-count indictment, which alleges numerous violations since 2006.
Goodman has pleaded not guilty.
The Forward first broke the news weeks ago that nearly 90 Orthodox men had been arrested on child abuse charges. At that time, prosecutors refused to furnish any additional information about the cases, but suggested they would do so by the end of November.
Among the cases reported by the Forward was that of Boro Park Rabbi Baruch Lebovits, who was sentenced last year to up to 32 years in prison after being convicted of sex abuse.
Victims’ rights advocates hailed it as a turning point in the battle against sexual abuse in the insular Orthodox community. But Lebovits is now free on bail and his conviction is now unraveling amid allegations of perjury, conspiracy and extortion.
Just last week, Hynes’ spokesman Jerry Schmetterer refused to return calls from the Forward asking for more information about the cases.
B'klyn perv in Orthodox sex abuse case takes judge's sweetheart deal
By Jose Martinez
New York Post - June 22, 2012
A pervert who sexually abused two Orthodox Jewish brothers accepted a judge's sweetheart deal today that will spring him from jail in September - over the furious objections of Brooklyn prosecutors.
Andrew Goodman pleaded guilty to 48 felonies - including criminal sex acts with a minor, sex abuse and sexual misconduct - after Justice Martin Murphy dangled a 2-year sentence in front of him.
Assistant District Attorney Kevin O'Donnell said prosecutors would have pursued a penalty that could have locked up Goodman for "dozens, if not hundreds of years."
"All right," Murphy said.
Goodman, who was arrested in June 2010 for preying on the boys over several years, was thrilled with the offer.
"It's an amazing deal," said Israel Fried, a defense lawyer for Goodman. "He's very happy to put this behind him, do his time and hopefully get on with his life.
"He was never looking to not take responsibility."
Community members had filmed Goodman sneaking 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home during pre-dawn hours, and trashed him as a "lifelong molestor who preys on young boys" in letters written to the judge.
Fried said prosecutors "weren't going to offer anything," charging they weren't going to go easy on Goodman because of the heavy criticism District Attorney Charles Hynes has taken for his handling of sex-abuse cases in Brooklyn's Orthodox Jewish community.
"These are the crimes de jour, so to speak and they're the ones that have put the District Attorney under the microscope," Fried said. "That's why they've taken such a hard line."
But Hynes fired back that prosecutors should "have the right to appeal a disposition taken over their objections."
"Here, an acting State Supreme Court Justice promised a sentence of two years to someone who pled guilty to 48 felonies," he said in a statement.
Goodman is the adopted son of a Jewish family and attended yeshivas in Israel through 2005.
He previously studied at a community college and did volunteer work with developmentally disabled adults.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Andrew Goodman gets just 2 years behind bars
By Oren Yaniv
New York Daily News - July 12, 2012
An admitted child molester stared at his teenage victim and professed his unending love for him Thursday in front of a shocked Brooklyn courtroom — but still got only two years behind bars.
The sickening display by Andrew Goodman, 27, came after one of his two victims begged Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy not to go so easy on the serial pedophile, who'll be back on the streets in two months after time served. Prosecutors also strongly objected to the plea agreement.
“Letting this man go is a very grave mistake," the boy, now 17, said as his body trembled. “I have no doubt he'll try to do the same thing to other children once he gets out."
Goodman admitted to sexually abusing the youth and his brother for four years, starting when they were 12 and 13.
The victim described how his handsome neighbor earned his trust by buying him gifts, taking him to restaurants and alienating him from his parents before pressuring him into having sex.
"You are the worst thing that ever happened to me," he told the defendant. "You are the devil disguised as a human."
When it was Goodman's turn to speak, he turned to the traumatized victim and told him "I love you" as the packed courtroom gasped and grunted in disbelief.
"I did and still do to this day love (you)," the predator added. "I fell in love with you and I wish I never allowed my sexual desires to get in the way of what I valued more, which is your friendship."
None of that — or pleas by the boys' mother and prosecutor Elizabeth Doerfler, who called the sentence "woefully low" — swayed the judge.
“You caused a lot of pain to all the complainants," Judge Murphy told Goodman. "The statements that you made today are ill-advised to say the least."
But without giving an explanation, he meted out the minimum allowable sentence that was agreed to after the former social worker pleaded to the entire 48-count indictment.
Prosecutors were seeking seven years in prison on each count, which would have added up to a de facto life sentence.
Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes said the sentence "defies logic and is frankly inexplicable."
Goodman will likely also have to register as a sex offender for life.
When he made bail after his 2010 arrest, concerned community members surreptitiously filmed numerous other boys leaving his Flatbush home in the early morning hours.
No additional cases emerged, but, after hearing about the surveillance, a different judge locked Goodman up in lieu of $1 million bail, meaning he's already served almost his entire sentence.
The boy described in court “four long and torturous years" in which Goodman groomed him then made him feel "bad and unappreciative" if he didn't succumb to the sexual come-ons.
As a result of the abuse, the teen said, he quit school, has no friends and is struggling to cope in social situations.
"This is a very dangerous man," he told the judge. "Not only because of the crimes he committed, but also because he has no remorse."
The victims' mother and other advocates warned that the lenient penalty will discourage others from going through the hardship of filing complaints. Brooklyn prosecutors have railed against intimidation some accusers face when bringing abuse allegations in the Jewish community.
____________________________________________________________________________________
B'klyn perv only gets 2 years behind bars after molesting boy for years
By Jose Martinez
New York Post - July 12, 2012
That's just twisted.
Pedophile Andrew Goodman today proudly declared his undying love for the boy he molested for years, as a Brooklyn judge stuck to a sweetheart deal to lock him up for a mere two years.
Standing just feet from his shaking 17-year-old victim, Goodman called the boy "my best friend in the whole world" and insisted "there was no malice involved" even after the boy pleaded with Justice Martin Murphy to undo the deal he gave to "the devil disguised as a human."
"Every second of every day, all that I think about is [you]," the creep said, calling the teen by his first name.
Andrew Goodman
Goodman, 27, last month accepted the two-year deal from Murphy upon pleading guilty to 48 felonies - or as the victim said, "even more than Jerry Sandusky."
Locked up since June 2010 on charges that he preyed sexually upon the victim and his brother, Goodman could be freed by September.
"I have no doubt he will try to do the same thing to other other children once he gets out," the victim said.
The teen, who dropped out of school after what he called "a torturous four years" of sex abuse from Goodman, then called for a much stiffer sentence for his tormentor.
"The best thing for you and society is if you're locked in a cage away from society - especially children," he said.
"Please, use your position to protect our children," the teen's mom asked the judge.
The red-faced Murphy wasn’t swayed from the two-year sentence -- which he admitted was the minimum Goodman faced -- nor did he offer much insight into it.
"Mr. Goodman, you caused a lot of pain to all the complainants," he said. "Your statement that you made today was ill-advised, to say the least."
Prosecutors had been seeking seven-year sentences for each of the 48 felonies - a punishment that could have landed Goodman a sentence of more than 200 years.
"The defendant cultivated the relationships to violate and sexually abuse these boys," said prosecutor Elizabeth Doerfler. "The abuse was not an isolated incident, but stretched over several years."
The victim said Goodman began grooming him seven years ago to be a sex-abuse target by showering him with gifts that included Rollerblades, a Playstation and restaurant meals.
"He began telling me he loved me," the teen said. "He slowly built up my trust and then began to alienate me from my family.
"Eventually, I began to trust him more than my own parents."
His hands shaking and his words dripping with disgust, the teen then tore into Goodman.
"Andrew Goodman, you are the devil disguised as a human," he said. "I trusted you with my life and you betrayed that trust."
The pervert turned him against his family, the victim said, and against his Orthodox Jewish faith.
"You are the worst thing that ever happened to me," he said. "A person that really loves me wouldn't take advantage of an innocent young child."
Community members had filmed Goodman, the adopted son of a Jewish family, sneaking 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home during pre-dawn hours.
"Andrew Goodman is a predator who is really good at what he does," said the mother of his two victims.
____________________________________________________________________________________
How Did Brooklyn Perv Andrew Goodman Get Off With A 2-Year Prison Sentence? Seriously...How?
By James King
The Village Voice - July 13, 2012
A Brooklyn pervert convicted of molesting a pair of brothers for years proudly declared during his sentencing hearing yesterday his unwavering love for one of his victims, a 17-year-old boy -- all as the boy sat just feet away, shaking in fear, before calling his abuser "the devil disguised as a human."
"Every second of every day, all that I think about is [you]," convicted creep Andrew Goodman reportedly said of his victim during his sentencing hearing yesterday.
Judge Martin Murphy shot back, telling Goodman that "Your statement that you made today was ill-advised, to say the least."
Only not really; Murphy's the same judge who signed off on a sweetheart, slap-on-the-wrist plea agreement for Goodman that puts the perv away for a mere two years -- despite the fact that he was charged with 48 pervert-related felonies for abusing the boys for years.
As one of the victims pointed out during yesterdays hearing, 48 counts is more than the number of crimes with which Penn State monster Jerry Sandusky was charged. Unlike Goodman, Sandusky will die in prison.
Goodman's been behind bars since his arrest in 2010, which means he could potentially be out on the streets -- possibly cuddling up to your kids -- by September.
So, how the fuck did this happen? Your guess is as good as ours -- the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office didn't respond to our request for an explanation.
Other news outlets have let the Brooklyn D.A. off the hook, placing the blame for the ridiculous deal on the shoulders of Murphy (New York Post, we're looking in your direction). But plea deals don't exist without prosecutors (a judge can either accept or reject the deal), which means the Brooklyn D.A. had to sign off on the shitty deal -- much to the apparent dismay of the victim, who told the court that "The best thing for [Goodman] and society is if you're locked in a cage away from society - especially children."
Oh, and if you think the sentence is appropriate, and Goodman will learn his lesson in two short years (read: if you're an idiot), Goodman's neighbors have video footage of him sneaking up to 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home in "predawn hours."
So, yeah -- this guy's gonna be a free man in a few months, and you can thank the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office and Judge Martin Murphy.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Community outraged: Brooklyn pedophile who 'loves' his victim gets only 2 years
By Raishad M. Hardnett
Metro - July 13, 2012
It's an unusual legal strategy, to say the least: 27-year-old Andrew Goodman, after admitting to molesting two teenaged Orthodox siblings, finished his courtroom statement by professing his undying love for one of them. But for whatever reason, even after blurting out, "I did and still do to this day love [you]," the consequences were unusually light for Goodman.
In a result that Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hyne says "defies logic and is frankly inexplicable," the judge sentenced the child offender to only two years in prison.
Andrew Goodman was charged with molesting the two brothers for four years, beginning when one was 11 years old and the other was 13. He plead guilty to a 48-count indictment – which is "even more [counts] than Jerry Sandusky" was found guilty of, a victim pointed out.
The case has stirred the discontentment of the Jewish community in Brooklyn, members of which banded together to collect evidence against Goodman.
In 2010 when Goodman paid a $1 million bail bond to return to his home in New York, community members gathered and allegedly recorded a video of numerous boys leaving his house in the early hours of the morning.
"Andrew Goodman is known in our community as a lifelong molester who preys on young boys and ruins their lives," a scholar at Congregation Bais Torah wrote to Judge Martin Murphy, according to a NY Post article.
The New York Daily News mentions four "long and torturous years" in which Goodman took advantage of the defendant by inviting him to restaurants and separating him from his parents. As a result, the teen said he no longer attends school and now struggles to hold healthy social relationships.
Goodman was convicted of three more counts of felony than Jerry Sandusky; however, at a time when Sandusky faces 373 years in prison for similar charges, several community members are outraged that Goodman, who has already spent some jail time, could actually be released from prison as early as September.
That means two months -- which means many pleas and demands for justice have fallen on deaf ears.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Light sentence for convicted molester is a perversion of justice
New York Daily News - July 14, 2012
AG Schneiderman should pursue civil commitment to keep Goodman behind bars.
Justice Martin Murphy's two-year sentence for molester Andrew Goodman is an outrage.
There may still be a way to ensure that a Brooklyn judge has not put
the public safety at risk by astonishly throwing wide the jailhouse
doors for a demented sex abuser.
State Attorney General Eric Schneiderman must intervene to determine
whether convicted molester Andrew Goodman is a candidate for civil
confinement in a mental hospital.
Over objections of enraged prosecutors and a trembling teenage victim,
acting Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy sentenced Goodman to just two
years — a term that expires in two months because Goodman has been held
since his arrest.
Murphy’s judgment that two years was sufficient punishment was, in a word, criminal.
Goodman, a social worker, admitted subjecting two boys to oral and anal
sex over four years, starting when they were were 12 and 13 years old.
Court papers show there was videotape evidence of 11 underage boys going
in and out of his home.
He pleaded guilty to committing 48 felony counts of criminal sexual
acts under a plea engineered by Murphy, who claimed, according to
judicial sources, that he wanted to spare the victims the trauma of a
trial. Never mind that the victims and families were fully prepared to
proceed.
“Letting this man go is a very grave mistake,” one victim, now 17, told
Murphy. “I have no doubt he’ll try to do the same thing to other
children once he gets out.” Chillingly, Goodman turned to the victim in
court and said, “I love you. I did and still to do this day.”
Murphy’s sentence flies in the face of a New York statute that
authorizes the attorney general to seek the indefinite
institutionalization of a sex offender after he has finished a prison
term if mental health authorities and a judge agree there is good reason
to believe he remains a threat.
Schneiderman and Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes, whose
deputy, Kevin O’Donnell, objected to Murphy’s madness, must join in
getting Goodman a civil-confinement review.
He is due for release under probation supervision in September. There’s no time to lose.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Brooklyn D.A. Mum On Slap-On-The-Wrist Plea Deal For Convicted Pervert Andrew Goodman
By James King
The Village Voice - July 17, 2012
On Friday, we asked the following question: How Did Brooklyn Perv Andrew Goodman Get Off With A 2-Year Prison Sentence?
The question wasn't meant to be rhetorical; we really want to know how a guy who was initially hit with 48 pervert-related felonies after admiting to sexually abusing two young boys -- before brazenly declaring his undying love for one of them at his sentencing hearing last week -- gets a mere two years behind bars.
Other media outlets have blamed the judge in the case, Martin Murphy, for the sweetheart deal that could potentially have Goodman back on the streets -- and around your kids -- by September. But plea deals -- even those of the sweetheart variety -- don't exist without the approval of a prosecutor, who in this case works for the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office, which has refused to give an explanation as to why Goodman was let so easily off the hook.
We've contacted the Brooklyn D.A.'s Office twice since Friday, both times asking for a simple explanation of the deal. We were ignored each time.
Just to be clear, we're not saying the Brooklyn D.A.'s Office is necessarily to blame for Goodman's slap on the wrist -- shitty plea deals happen sometimes, especially when prosecutors don't think they have enough evidence to get a conviction on a more serious charge.
For example, while working for the Voice's sister publication in Phoenix, Arizona, we wrote an article about a Jehovah's Witness elder who got sentenced to a scant six months in county jail after admitting to repeatedly abusing a teenage boy over the span of several years. The Maricopa County Attorney's Office (after initially lying to us about the circumstances surrounding the deal) explained that "time stamps" (events -- in this case the release of the movie "Porky's" -- that specifically indicate when something happened) were inconsistent with the victim's story, and it therefor couldn't be proven that he was 14 years old at the time of the abuse.
Under Arizona law, the age of the victim plays an enormous role in the severity of the punishment for their abusers -- and 15 is the age at which the punishment gets much less severe. Because it couldn't be proven that the victim was 14 at the time of the abuse, the county attorney says he was forced to cut the elder a deal -- even though the perv admitted to the abuse long before a deal was ever presented to him.
We didn't quite buy the county attorney's explanation (given some other facts surrounding the case), but at least one was offered. The same cannot be said about the Brooklyn D.A.
In Goodman's case, in addition to professing his love for the victim in open court as recently as last week, his neighbors have video footage of him sneaking up to 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home in "predawn hours." In other words -- and if pervert history tells us anything -- this probably won't be the last time Brooklyn D.A. Charles Hynes hears the name Andrew Goodman, and if/when he re-offends, Hynes probably will have much more explaining to do.
Oh -- just to reiterate -- Goodman could be a free man as soon as September, so hide yo' kids!.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Brooklyn D.A. Mum On Slap-On-The-Wrist Plea Deal For Convicted Pervert Andrew Goodman
By James King
The Village Voice - July 17, 2012
On Friday, we asked the following question: How Did Brooklyn Perv Andrew Goodman Get Off With A 2-Year Prison Sentence?
The question wasn't meant to be rhetorical; we really want to know how a guy who was initially hit with 48 pervert-related felonies after admiting to sexually abusing two young boys -- before brazenly declaring his undying love for one of them at his sentencing hearing last week -- gets a mere two years behind bars.
Other media outlets have blamed the judge in the case, Martin Murphy, for the sweetheart deal that could potentially have Goodman back on the streets -- and around your kids -- by September. But plea deals -- even those of the sweetheart variety -- don't exist without the approval of a prosecutor, who in this case works for the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office, which has refused to give an explanation as to why Goodman was let so easily off the hook.
We've contacted the Brooklyn D.A.'s Office twice since Friday, both times asking for a simple explanation of the deal. We were ignored each time.
Just to be clear, we're not saying the Brooklyn D.A.'s Office is necessarily to blame for Goodman's slap on the wrist -- shitty plea deals happen sometimes, especially when prosecutors don't think they have enough evidence to get a conviction on a more serious charge.
For example, while working for the Voice's sister publication in Phoenix, Arizona, we wrote an article about a Jehovah's Witness elder who got sentenced to a scant six months in county jail after admitting to repeatedly abusing a teenage boy over the span of several years. The Maricopa County Attorney's Office (after initially lying to us about the circumstances surrounding the deal) explained that "time stamps" (events -- in this case the release of the movie "Porky's" -- that specifically indicate when something happened) were inconsistent with the victim's story, and it therefor couldn't be proven that he was 14 years old at the time of the abuse.
Under Arizona law, the age of the victim plays an enormous role in the severity of the punishment for their abusers -- and 15 is the age at which the punishment gets much less severe. Because it couldn't be proven that the victim was 14 at the time of the abuse, the county attorney says he was forced to cut the elder a deal -- even though the perv admitted to the abuse long before a deal was ever presented to him.
We didn't quite buy the county attorney's explanation (given some other facts surrounding the case), but at least one was offered. The same cannot be said about the Brooklyn D.A.
In Goodman's case, in addition to professing his love for the victim in open court as recently as last week, his neighbors have video footage of him sneaking up to 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home in "predawn hours." In other words -- and if pervert history tells us anything -- this probably won't be the last time Brooklyn D.A. Charles Hynes hears the name Andrew Goodman, and if/when he re-offends, Hynes probably will have much more explaining to do.
Oh -- just to reiterate -- Goodman could be a free man as soon as September, so hide yo' kids!.
FBI PRESS RELEASE
US Attorney's Office - Eastern District of New York
(718) 254-7000
July 25, 2012
Brooklyn Man Charged with Transporting a Minor in Interstate Commerce to Engage in Sexual Activity Defendant Allegedly Took Victim to Atlantic City
A complaint was unsealed this morning in federal court in
Brooklyn charging Andrew Goodman with transporting a minor in
interstate commerce to engage in sexual activity. Goodman’s initial
appearance is scheduled later today before United States Magistrate
Judge Cheryl L. Pollak, at the U.S. Courthouse, 225 Cadman Plaza East in
Brooklyn, New York.
The charge was announced by Loretta E. Lynch, United States Attorney
for the Eastern District of New York, and Janice K. Fedarcyk, Assistant
Director in Charge, Federal Bureau of Investigation, New York Field
Office.
As alleged in the complaint, in February 2010, Goodman traveled with
the then 15-year-old victim to Atlantic City, New Jersey. While there,
Goodman sexually abused the victim in a hotel room.
“The prevention of sexual exploitation of children is a priority of
this office,” stated United States Attorney Lynch. “Those who would take
advantage of children are on notice that they will be prosecuted to the
full extent of the law.” Ms. Lynch extended her grateful appreciation
to District Attorney Charles J. Hynes and the Kings County District
Attorney’s Office for their assistance in this case.
FBI Assistant Director in Charge Fedarcyk stated, “Those who sexually
exploit children will be held to justice for all the crimes they commit
under both federal and local laws. In this case, Mr. Goodman allegedly
transported a minor across state lines with the intent to sexually abuse
a child. The FBI and our law enforcement partners remain committed to
protecting children from predators.”
If convicted, the defendant faces a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years’ imprisonment and a maximum of life imprisonment.
The government’s case is being prosecuted by Assistant United States Attorney Tyler Smith.
The charge is merely an allegation, and the defendant is presumed innocent unless and until proven guilty.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Andrew Goodman, Perv Who Got Smooch-On-The-Wrist Plea Deal, Could Be Federally F**ked
By James King
The Village Voice - July 25, 2012
Andrew Goodman received a sweetheart plea deal from the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office that landed him behind bars for a mere two years for repeatedly molesting two young boys. Now the feds have stepped in, and Goodman's looking at an additional sentence of at least 10 years, if convicted of the new federal charges.
At the sentencing hearing earlier this month for convicted Brooklyn pervert Andrew Goodman, the pederast was so happy about the wimpy sentence he was set to receive (thanks to a sweetheart plea deal from the Brooklyn District Attorney's Office) that he used the court appearance to declare his undying love for one of the young, male victims of his perverse sexual appetite.
"Every second of every day, all that I think about is [you]," Goodman told the court, while staring at one of his teen victims.
He was then sentenced to a scant two-year prison sentence, which would have potentially had him back on the streets by October because of time he's already served.
Unfortunately for Goodman (but fortunately for every child in New York City), the feds have stepped in -- all because Goodman had the bright idea to take one of his victims to Atlantic City, making it an interstate commerce issue, which falls under federal authority, according to a criminal complaint obtained by the Voice.
Now, rather than two short years behind bars, Goodman is looking at a mandatory minimum sentence of 10 years in prison if convicted.
Funny how the universe has a tendency to correct itself, ay?
According to the complaint, following Goodman's sentencing on July 12, one of his victims was interviewed by federal authorities After explaining to the federal agent that Goodman began molesting him in 2006 -- when the boy was only 11 -- and continued molesting him until his arrest in 2011, the victim told the agent about the February 13, 2010, trip to the gambling hot-spot, where he says he also was sexually abused by Goodman.
Additionally, the boy says, two of Goodman's adult friends also went on the trip.
According to the complaint, the three adults gambled at the Trump Taj Mahal Casino before getting two rooms in the casino's hotel.
The boy told authorities that the two friends stayed in one room, while he and Goodman stayed in the other.
The room had two beds, and Goodman and the boy initially started out sleeping separately, the boy told investigators Soon after, however, Goodman weaseled his way into the boys bed, where he sodomized him and forced him to perform oral sex. Then the creep allegedly forced the boy to take a shower with him.
The next day, Goodman and the boy had breakfast at a diner before going to a Kid Rock concert at the Borgata Casino. The next day, Goodman put the boy on a bus back to Brooklyn.
To verify the boy's story, authorities checked Kid Rock's concert schedule, and sure enough, he played a show at the Borgata on February 14, 2010.
Goodman is a grade-A creep -- in addition to the abuse for which he's been convicted, his neighbors have video footage of him sneaking up to 11 underage boys in and out of his 15th Street home in "predawn hours." Considering he had no problem expressing his unwavering affection for his young victim, it seems pretty clear that two short years in jail isn't gonna break him of his pedophilia habit. Not that 10 years would, either, but at least he'd only be around other convicted criminals, and not sneaking young boys into his apartment in the middle of the night.
____________________________________________________________________________________
Convicted molester may face life
By John Marzulli
New York Daily News - July 25, 2012
Andrew Goodman facing charge of interstate transportation of a minor for the purpose of sexual assault
A convicted child molester who got off with a measly two-year sentence
from a Brooklyn judge was slapped with federal charges Wednesday that
could put him away for the rest of his life.
When Andrew Goodman was sentenced in state Supreme Court last month on 48 counts of sexually abusing two young brothers, the creep professed his love for one of the victims, who was present in the courtroom.
The shocking statement didn’t faze Justice Martin Murphy who went ahead and gave Goodman a slap on the wrist.
But Goodman now faces a damning complaint charging him with the interstate transportation of a minor for the purpose of sexual assault.
Goodman, 27, is accused of traveling with the then-15-year-old victim in February 2010 to Atlantic City where he raped and sodomized the boy in a hotel room. If convicted, Goodman faces a mandatory minimum of 10 years in prison and a maximum of life.
When Andrew Goodman was sentenced in state Supreme Court last month on 48 counts of sexually abusing two young brothers, the creep professed his love for one of the victims, who was present in the courtroom.
The shocking statement didn’t faze Justice Martin Murphy who went ahead and gave Goodman a slap on the wrist.
But Goodman now faces a damning complaint charging him with the interstate transportation of a minor for the purpose of sexual assault.
Goodman, 27, is accused of traveling with the then-15-year-old victim in February 2010 to Atlantic City where he raped and sodomized the boy in a hotel room. If convicted, Goodman faces a mandatory minimum of 10 years in prison and a maximum of life.
____________________________________________________________________________________
B'klyn perv could be locked up for life
By Jose Martinez
New York Post - July 25, 2012
A Brooklyn child molester who was recently given a two-year prison sentence by a judge in a shocking sweetheart deal was smacked today with federal charges that could lock him up for life.
Unrepentant perv Andrew Goodman — who creepily told his trembling teen-age victim “I love you” at his July 12 sentencing before state Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy — was charged by the feds with having sex with the same boy in a New Jersey hotel room in 2010, then taking him to a Kid Rock concert in Atlantic City.
If convicted of transporting a minor in interstate commerce to engage in sexual activity, Goodman will serve a mandatory minimum of 10 years in federal prison and could face up to a life sentence.
“It is an incredibly serious charge,” said Assistant US Attorney
Tyler Smith. “The case against the defendant is also incredibly strong.”
Murphy’s lenient punishment — and Goodman’s outrageous courtroom antics in front of his victim — drew fierce criticism when the 27-year-old sicko was sentenced for molesting the 17-year-old boy and his brother over several years.
“He’s shown himself to be essentially remorseless,” Smith said, noting how Goodman professed his undying love for his victim at his sentencing, a gesture which drew gasps of disgust.
Goodman was arrested in 2010, and could have completed his sentence by September. Now he’ll be in federal custody, likely in a single cell under a 23-hour lockdown.
“As he approached the end of his sentence, he was certainly surprised that they were seeking to prosecute him further,” said his court-appointed lawyer. Michael Padden. “I don’t think that he saw this coming.”
But Brooklyn District Attorney, who strongly opposed Murphy’s sentence, applauded the move to nail Goodman on federal charges.
“I am pleased that US Attorney Loretta Lynch made the decision to prosecute Andrew Goodman,” Hynes said.
____________________________________________________________________________________ B'klyn perv could be locked up for life
By Jose Martinez
New York Post - July 25, 2012
A Brooklyn child molester who was recently given a two-year prison sentence by a judge in a shocking sweetheart deal was smacked today with federal charges that could lock him up for life.
Unrepentant perv Andrew Goodman — who creepily told his trembling teen-age victim “I love you” at his July 12 sentencing before state Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy — was charged by the feds with having sex with the same boy in a New Jersey hotel room in 2010, then taking him to a Kid Rock concert in Atlantic City.
If convicted of transporting a minor in interstate commerce to engage in sexual activity, Goodman will serve a mandatory minimum of 10 years in federal prison and could face up to a life sentence.
Murphy’s lenient punishment — and Goodman’s outrageous courtroom antics in front of his victim — drew fierce criticism when the 27-year-old sicko was sentenced for molesting the 17-year-old boy and his brother over several years.
“He’s shown himself to be essentially remorseless,” Smith said, noting how Goodman professed his undying love for his victim at his sentencing, a gesture which drew gasps of disgust.
Goodman was arrested in 2010, and could have completed his sentence by September. Now he’ll be in federal custody, likely in a single cell under a 23-hour lockdown.
“As he approached the end of his sentence, he was certainly surprised that they were seeking to prosecute him further,” said his court-appointed lawyer. Michael Padden. “I don’t think that he saw this coming.”
But Brooklyn District Attorney, who strongly opposed Murphy’s sentence, applauded the move to nail Goodman on federal charges.
“I am pleased that US Attorney Loretta Lynch made the decision to prosecute Andrew Goodman,” Hynes said.
Finally a hero to protect the kids
Bill O'Reilly
Fox News - July 26, 2012
____________________________________________________________________________________
Pedophile victim faces abuser in court a second time, after state judge gave monster only two-year sentence
By John Marzulli
New York Daily News - October 10, 2012
Admitted child molester Andrew Goodman faces new federal charges, could get put away for life.
Andrew Goodman, 27, who
worked for Jewish social service agencies, is charged with sexually
abusing two Orthodox boys for years in Flatbush.
The teen victim of a remorseless child molester faced his abuser for a
traumatic second round, determined that the monster be put away for
longer than the paltry two-year sentence handed down by a state judge
over the summer.
If not for the new federal charges, admitted pedophile Andrew Goodman, 28, would be a free man, having completed that sentence with credit for time-served.
"I want to see that there's justice, and hopefully there will be," the victim, now 17, told The Daily News outside court.
The feds stepped in to charge Goodman in July after he received the outrageously short sentence from Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy for abusing the victim and his younger brother for years, starting when they were 12 and 13. The victims and Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes had strongly objected to the slap on the wrist.
Adding insult to injury, at Goodman’s sentencing for molesation, he even turned to the older brother and professed his undying love, adding, “I wish I never allowed my sexual desires to get in the way of what I valued more, which is your friendship."
Goodman pleaded not guilty Wednesday to the two new charges contained in the federal indictment — traveling across state lines with the older brother to Atlantic City, where he raped and sodomized the 15-year-old boy in a hotel room; and using a telephone to coerce a minor for the purpose of a sexual assault.
If found guilty, Goodman could be sent away for life.
The victim said he plans to continue attending the federal court proceedings as he did in state court.
"I'm not afraid because he (Goodman) is in jail clothes — if he wasn't, I would be," the victim said.
Defense lawyer Michael Padden declined to comment on the case.
If convicted of that charge, Federal Judge Margo Brodie could consider all sex crimes committed by Goodman, not just the federal charges related to the Atlantic City trip with the victim, according to a source familiar with the case.
Murphy, the state judge, never explained the reason for the light sentence, ignoring the words of the victim who called Goodman "the devil disguised as a human."
____________________________________________________________________________________If not for the new federal charges, admitted pedophile Andrew Goodman, 28, would be a free man, having completed that sentence with credit for time-served.
"I want to see that there's justice, and hopefully there will be," the victim, now 17, told The Daily News outside court.
The feds stepped in to charge Goodman in July after he received the outrageously short sentence from Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Martin Murphy for abusing the victim and his younger brother for years, starting when they were 12 and 13. The victims and Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes had strongly objected to the slap on the wrist.
Adding insult to injury, at Goodman’s sentencing for molesation, he even turned to the older brother and professed his undying love, adding, “I wish I never allowed my sexual desires to get in the way of what I valued more, which is your friendship."
Goodman pleaded not guilty Wednesday to the two new charges contained in the federal indictment — traveling across state lines with the older brother to Atlantic City, where he raped and sodomized the 15-year-old boy in a hotel room; and using a telephone to coerce a minor for the purpose of a sexual assault.
If found guilty, Goodman could be sent away for life.
The victim said he plans to continue attending the federal court proceedings as he did in state court.
"I'm not afraid because he (Goodman) is in jail clothes — if he wasn't, I would be," the victim said.
Defense lawyer Michael Padden declined to comment on the case.
If convicted of that charge, Federal Judge Margo Brodie could consider all sex crimes committed by Goodman, not just the federal charges related to the Atlantic City trip with the victim, according to a source familiar with the case.
Murphy, the state judge, never explained the reason for the light sentence, ignoring the words of the victim who called Goodman "the devil disguised as a human."
Brave teenager comes face to face with abuser in court after judge gave moleser two-yar sentence
Daily Mail - October 11, 2012
A teenage sex abuse victim mustered up the courage to face his abuser in court on Wednesday, as the scarred boy hopes to see justice served despite the lax sentence handed down to the convicted child molester.
Andrew Goldman, 28, pleaded guilty on two counts of child molestation in June for abusing two Orthodox Jewish boys in Flatbush, Brooklyn. But he was only given a two year jail sentence, which given his time served would mean he would soon be back out on the streets.
But now a federal indictment for child sex abuse could mean that the man, described as a child predator, could stay behind bars for good.
Goldman, who worked at a Jewish social service agency, aggressively pursued young boys in the Orthodox community in Brooklyn.
Goodman would visit the playgrounds of yeshivas, Jewish religious schools, to meet boys and also hosted alcohol fueled parties for the boys, where he would screen child pornography, according to prosecutors.
He was also accused of taping his sexual assault on his victims with a web cam.
As part of an initiative to bring child sex abusers to justice, Kol Tzedek, Hebrew for 'voice of justice,' Goodman was arrested in July 2010 on suspicion of molesting young boys.
Shockingly, he was released on bail and in his days out of prison, he was seen inviting young boys to the Brooklyn home he shared with his mother and sister.
When surveillance video showed the boys entering the home in the early morning hours, he was re-arrested and held on $1 million bail where he has remained since 2010.
In July 2012, he pleaded guilty to two counts of sexually abusing two brothers, starting when they were 12 and 13, over a period of several years.
'Andrew Goodman is known in our community as a lifelong molester who preys on young boys and ruins their lives,' a Talmudic scholar at Congregation Bais Torah wrote to Brooklyn Judge Martin Murphy, according to the New York Post.
But there was public outcry over when Judge Murphy handed down a lenient sentence of only two years to Goldman. Given his time served, Goldman would be eligible to walk in September 2012.
But a federal indictment now means new charges for Goldman and the chance that he could stay jailed for life.
He has been charged with traveling across state lines with one of his victims to Atlantic City, where he allegedly raped and sodomized the 15-year-old in a hotel room, in addition to using a telephone to coerce a minor into sex.
Goodman pleaded not guilty to the charges on Wednesday but a conviction could mean he faces life in prison.
'I want to see that there's justice, and hopefully there will be,' the victim, now 17, told The Daily News, saying he plans to attend the federal court proceedings.
____________________________________________________________________________________
FAIR USE NOTICE
Some of the information on The Awareness Center's web pages may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc.
We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml . If you wish to use copyrighted material from this update for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.
____________________________________________________________________________________
No comments:
Post a Comment