Thursday, March 08, 1990

Case of Mordechai Ehrman

Case of Mordechai Ehrman
(AKA: Morton Ehrman)
Simcha's Play Group - Brooklyn, NY
Pelham, NY
Lakewood, NJ
 
 
Accused of molesting dozens of young students.

If anyone has a photograph of Mordechai Ehrman, please forward it to The Awareness Center.
___________________________________________________________________________________
 
Disclaimer: Inclusion in this website does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement. Individuals must decide for themselves if the resources meet their own personal needs.

Table of Contents 

1990 
  1. Day-Care Abuse Alleged B'klyn DA investigates charges at Midwood center  (03/08/1990)
  2. Inquiry Begun Into Claim Of Child Abuse at Center  (03/09/1990)
  3. Preschool Owner Denies Sex Charges (03/09/1990)
  4. Child-abuse claims probed; N.Y. day-care centre for Orthodox Jews is under investigation, assemblyman says  (03/10/1990)
  5. Other news to note (03/10/1990)
  6. B'klyn Rabbis Back Sex-Abuse Charges (05/15/1990)
  7. In the matter of  Morton Ehrman, Appellant, v. Cesar A. Perales, etc., Et Al. Respondents (06/19/1990)
  8. Food Stamp Charges Stick to B'klyn Man (08/16/1990)
     
___________________________________________________________________________________

Day-Care Abuse Alleged B'klyn DA investigates charges at Midwood center
Newsday - March 8, 1990


District Attorney Charles Hynes
The Brooklyn district attorney's office is investigating allegations of sexual abuse at a closed preschool for Orthodox Jewish youngsters, according to sources close to both the investigation and the targets. While prosecutors say "there is no hard evidence" to justify formal charges, the probe has thrown the Midwood neighborhood into turmoil. 

Assistant district attorneys have questioned dozens of children between 2 1/2 and 5 years old in connection with the investigation begun last fall into the Simcha Play Group, a 5-year-old day-care center operated by Mordechai and Tovah Ehrman. 

A source close to the investigation said it centers on allegations that some of the children were improperly "touched" at the school, but added that the children "have been unable to identify who touched them." 

The Ehrmans, who operated the center at their home, closed it when the probe became known. 

David Stern, a cousin of Mordechai Ehrman and the attorney who represented him until the case was recently taken over by the law office of Barry Slotnick, said the Ehrman family "has been subjected to months of unjustified mental torture, harassment, false criminal charges and a campaign of intimidation." 

"The true issue is how long the community is going to permit the destruction of an innocent family by sitting silently by," he said. 

Stern said that Mordechai Ehrman, who has been the target of parents' accusations, voluntarily asked Brooklyn prosecutors to investigate the allegations when they were first made in October. Stern said Ehrman became aware of allegations when an caseworker for the city Child Welfare Administration began a probe of cases involving four children. The city later decided not take further action, Stern said, and Ehrman provided the names of those children to prosecutors. 

He also said that Ehrman, who drove a bus for the school which was operated by his wife, voluntarily took and passed a lie detector test organized by a state official. 

A spokesman for Brooklyn District Attorney Charles J. Hynes, meanwhile, would not confirm if an investigation is under way. 

But Assemb. Dov Hikind (D-Borough Park), who has been encouraging parents to cooperate with the investigation, said Hynes met in his office last month with 70 parents, some of whom complained that the children have not been properly interviewed by psychologically trained questioners. Hikind said Hynes promised a thorough investigation. 

"There is no doubt that terrible things happened to little children, that acts of sexual abuse happened, in that school," Hikind said yesterday, before leaving for a Purim vacation in Israel. "We have to convince the parents to trust the criminal justice system and talk to investigators and let it work." 

Some of the rumors have been fed by an anonymous poster put up in the area charging both Ehrmans with taking part in sexual abuse of the children. 

The source, however, said Tovah Ehrman has not been implicated in the allegations. The source said the questioning of children is expected to continue until the end of the month, and that a decision would be made then as to whether the case would be turned over to a grand jury. 

Stern said a campaign of harassment aimed based on the allegations has resulted in one daughter getting fired from a job and a teenaged daughter getting turned down for babysitting jobs. 

Some of the parents say that Kalman Finkel, a member of the state Law Revision Commission appointed by Gov. Mario Cuomo, has entered the case on Ehrman's behalf. 

But Finkel said yesterday he did nothing to impede the investigation. Finkel said he asked a staff member of the Legal Aid Society to give Ehrman a lie detector test, which Ehrman passed, and that he contacted rabbis to help set up a rabbinical court to consider the case. 

Hikind yesterday said a rabbinical court does not have "the authority or the power" to resolve a criminal case.
___________________________________________________________________________________

Inquiry Begun Into Claim Of Child Abuse At Center
By Frank J. Prial
The New York Times - March 9, 1990
The Brooklyn District Attorney is investigating claims that dozens of children were sexually molested at a now-closed unlicensed day-care center in Brooklyn last year, according to participants in the case.
 
A spokesman for District Attorney Charles J. Hynes refused to confirm or deny that an investigation was under way, but Assemblyman Dov Hikind, a Brooklyn Democrat, said he and more than 70 parents of children who had attended the school met with Mr. Hynes on Feb. 6 to discuss what they contended was slow progress in the investigation.
 
The operator of the school was Mordechai (Morton) Ehrman, participants in the case said. He ran the school, known as the Simcha Play Group, at his home at 1444 East Fifth Street in the Midwood section. Working with him were his wife, Tova, several of his 10 children and an undetermined number of hired teachers, participants in the case said.
 
Mr. Ehrman's lawyer, his cousin, David Stern, said that four complaints by parents about the Ehrmans had been investigated by the Special Services for Children Division of the Human Resources Department. He said the files had been closed earlier this year for lack of evidence.
'No One Gives a Damn'
 
He said that the Ehrmans had been intimidated, threatened and harassed since the allegations first surfaced last year, and that they had received no help from the city. ''No one gives a damn,'' he said.
The controversy, which was reported yesterday in New York Newsday and The Daily News, has prompted several angry encounters between the Ehrmans and parents, participants in the case said. Several weeks ago, Mr. Ehrman went to court to answer charges of harassment brought by one father, Sam Antar. The case was postponed.
 
No charges have been filed against Mr. Ehrman or anyone in his family, but Mr. Hikind said he understood that evidence was being heard in the case.
 
Reached by telephone in Israel, where he is vacationing, Mr. Hikind said parents first began coming to him last fall. ''Some of them didn't even want to tell me their names,'' he said.
Dozens of Children Questioned
 
NY Assemblyman Dov Hikind
Mr. Hikind said dozens of children had been question by assistant district attorneys since the investigation began.
 
All the families involved are Orthodox Jews, Mr. Hikind said, and some had been cautioned by their rabbis not to make their complaints public because they might embarrass the Jewish community. The Ehrmans are Orthodox Jews, too, and advertised their day-care center as a school for Orthodox Jewish children.
 
Mr. Hikind said the controversy began when a mother went to her rabbi complaining that her 3-year-old daughter had been molested at the school. Mr. Hikind said some rabbis in the neighborhood encourged parents to press charges against the Ehrmans. ''Some rabbis even urged them from the pulpit,'' he said.
 
Mr. Stern said Mr. Ehrman first heard the accusations when he was summoned before a Beth Din, a traditional rabbinical tribunal. ''They demanded that he sign away his right to deal with children for the rest of his life,'' Mr. Stern said.
 
Accusations of Rape and Fondling
 
Mr. Ehrman refused and called Mr. Stern, a former assistant district attorney in Brooklyn, who said he called the District Attorney's office and demanded an investigation. ''I sent the District Attorney the names of all the children in the school and all the children in the summer program,'' he said.
 
Mr. Ehrman later demanded another rabbinical court so he could present his side of the controversy. ''They met three weeks ago, but not since,'' Mr. Stern said.
 
According to Mr. Hikind, the charges against the Ehrmans include sexual abuses ranging from fondling to rape. ''There are some things I can't bring myself to discuss, even on the telephone,'' the Assemblyman said.
 
Mr. Stern said anonymous phone calls about the controversy had cost Mr. Ehrman and one of his daughters the jobs they had taken after they closed the school.
 
GRAPHIC: Photo: A former day-care center at 1444 East Fifth Street in the Midwood section of Brooklyn is under investigation by the Brooklyn District Attorney concerning charges that children were sexually molested there last year, according to participants in the case. (The New York Times/Vic DeLucia)
___________________________________________________________________________________

Preschool Owner Denies Sex Charges
By Bob Liff
Newsday - March 9, 1990

As several parents yesterday continued to say their children were sexually abused at a closed Brooklyn preschool for Orthodox Jewish youngsters, the owner of the preschool denied the charges and said she and her husband will be vindicated. 

Meanwhile, the predominantly Orthodox Jewish neighborhood of Midwood, where Mordechai and Tova Ehrman ran the Simcha Play Group from their home, was embroiled in a bitter round of accusations and counteraccusations growing out of parents' claims that more than 50 children were abused at the preschool. 

As many as 60 children from the ages of 2 1/2 to 5 have been interviewed by assistants to Brooklyn District Attorney Charles J. Hynes, and perhaps five of the children's comments are being further investigated, a source familiar with the case said yesterday. The source said while some medical evidence exists indicating abuse might have occurred, it is inconclusive and has not been linked to Mordechai Ehrman, who also drove the bus for the preschool operated by his wife. The couple closed the preschool in the fall when allegations first surfaced. 

An investigation by the city's Child Welfare Administration into allegations involving two children led to a letter the Ehrmans received late yesterday from the state Department of Social Services - which has oversight for city child abuse investigations - deeming those accusations "unfounded," according to A. David Stern, Ehrman's attorney and cousin. 

"No credible evidence was found that the child (children) has been abused or maltreated," the letter said, as read by Stern. "The report has therefore been considered unfounded." 

Soon after accusations began spreading in the neighborhood in October that Ehrman, 49, had abused children, he was called before a special rabbinical court - where observant Jews often resolve differences - and ordered to sign what Ehrman described as a confession. 

Ehrman, an Orthodox Jew, refused, and sent out an open letter to "parents and rabbis" in which he called the accusations "vile and disgusting," and said they were "false and slanderous." 

Some neighborhood leaders say the community is split between Syrian-born parents who are Sephardic Jews, who are cooperating with Hynes' investigation, and Hasidic and Orthodox Jewish parents of European descent, who wanted to keep the dispute before a Beth Din, or rabbinical court. 

On several occasions over the last five months, angry parents confronted Ehrman at his East Fifth Street house, according to Ehrman and parents. One occasion resulted in fisticuffs between Ehrman and the father of one of the children, with each man filing charges against the other. 

"We are the only victims here, my husband, my children and me," Tova Ehrman, who started the preschool six years ago, said yesterday. The couple has 10 children. She described the allegations against her husband as "total lies and falsehoods, willful and calculated." 

While anonymous posters in Midwood accuse Ehrman's wife of taking part in abuse, an investigative source said Wednesday no allegations have been made involving Tova Ehrman. 

"Only him," the source said. Ehrman has cooperated with investigators, and voluntarily took a lie detector test, which he passed, according to documents supplied to investigators by Stern. 

Meanwhile, four parents of children who attended the preschool yesterday called New York Newsday to say their children, some as young as 3 years old, described events the parents called sexual abuse.
"My son has been waking up every night screaming," said the mother of a 4 1/2-year-old boy who, she said, has a scar on his penis that doctors believe may be the result of abuse. "You tell me how a child that age can even make up these things." 

Another Brooklyn mother yesterday said her daughter, who was 4 when she attended the preschool, described games involving many children that the mother described as abuse. State Assemb. Dov Hikind, D-Borough Park, who brought 70 parents to meet with Hynes last month, said Wednesday "there is no doubt terrible things happened" at the preschool. 

___________________________________________________________________________________
 
Child-abuse claims probed; N.Y. day-care centre for Orthodox Jews is under investigation, assemblyman says 
By Frank J. Prial
The Gazette - March 10, 1990

NEW YORK - The Brooklyn district attorney is investigating charges that dozens of children were sexually molested last year at an unlicensed day-care centre in Brooklyn which has now closed, according to participants in the case. 

A spokesman for district attorney Charles Hynes refused to confirm or deny that an investigation was under way, but the Democratic assemblyman from Brooklyn, Dov Hikind, said he and more than 70 parents of children who had attended the school met with Hynes on Feb. 6 to discuss what they contended was slow progress in the investigation. 

The operator of the school was Mordechai "Morton" Ehrman, participants in the case said. He ran the school, known as the Simcha Play Group, at his home in the Midwood section. 

Working with him at the school were his wife, Tova, several of his 10 children and an undetermined number of hired teachers. 

Ehrman's lawyer, his cousin, David Stern, said that four complaints by parents about the Ehrmans had been investigated by the Special Services for Children division of the Human Resources Department. 

He said the files had been closed this year for lack of evidence. 

He said that the Ehrmans had been subject to a campaign of intimidation, threats and harassment since the charges first surfaced last year and that they had received no help from the city. 

"No one gives a damn," he said. 

No charges have been filed against Ehrman or anyone in his family, but Hikind said he understood that evidence is being heard in the case. 

All the families involved are Orthodox Jews, Hikind said, and some had been cautioned by their rabbis not to make their complaints public because they might embarrass the Jewish community. 

Other rabbis in the neighborhood encourged the parents to press charges against the Ehrmans. "Some rabbis even urged them from the pulpit," Hikind said. 

___________________________________________________________________________________
 
Other news to note
Orlando Sentinel - March 10, 1990 

DAY-CARE TROUBLES. The Brooklyn district attorney is investigating charges that dozens of children were sexually molested at a now- closed, unlicensed day-care center in Brooklyn last year, participants in the case say. A spokesman for District Attorney Charles J. Hynes refused to confirm or deny that an investigation was under way, but Assemblyman Dov Hikind, D-Brooklyn, said he and more than 70 parents of children who had attended the school met with Hynes on Feb. 6 to discuss what they contended was slow progress in the investigation. The operator of the school was Mordechai "Morton" Ehrman, participants in the case said. He ran the school, known as the Simcha Play Group, at his home. The controversy first came to light when a mother went to her rabbi complaining that her 3-year- old daughter had been molested at the school.  
___________________________________________________________________________________
 
B'klyn Rabbis Back Sex-Abuse Charges
By Alexis Jetter 
Newsday - May 15, 1990

"Both the accusers and the accused have been waiting for this Jewish court to act," said Assemb. Dov Hikind (D-Brooklyn). "They are very respected, and now that they have made a very clear statement in regard to this, I hope the DA's office will follow through." 

They formally requested that Ehrman continue to abide by a pledge, which they said he signed in October, 1989, to refrain from opening another preschool while the investigation is continuing. Ehrman closed the school in the fall when allegations first surfaced. 

Some neighborhood leaders said the Bais Din was necessary because Hasidic and Orthodox Jewish parents of European descent preferred to keep the matter before a Jewish court. Syrian-born, Sephardic Jews whose children were allegedly abused are said to be cooperating with the District Attorney's office.
___________________________________________________________________________________
  
IN THE MATTER OF MORTON EHRMAN, APPELLANT, v. CESAR A. PERALES, ETC., ET AL., RESPONDENTS
June 18, 1990

In a proceeding pursuant to CPLR article 78, inter alia, to review a determination of the respondent Commissioner of the New York State Department of Social Services, dated August 20, 1985, which denied the petitioner's application for food stamp benefits, the petitioner appeals from an order and judgment (one paper) of the Supreme Court, Kings County (Hutcherson, J.), dated September 27, 1988, which denied his motion for an award of attorneys' fees pursuant to 42 USC ? 1988.
Lawrence J. Bracken, J.p., Sybil Hart Kooper, Isaac Rubin, Sondra Miller, JJ.
DECISION & ORDER


Contrary to the petitioner's contention, we conclude that the Supreme Court properly denied his request for attorney's fees pursuant to 42 USC ? 1988 inasmuch as his cause of action is not a bona fide civil rights cause of action pursuant to 42 USC ? 1983 (see, Matter of Cruz v Perales, A.D.2d [2d Dept., Feb. 20, 1990]; Matter of Rashid v Perales, A.D.2d [2d Dept., Dec., 26, 1989]).
Disposition

___________________________________________________________________________________

Food Stamp Charges Stick to B'klyn Man
By Patricia Hurtado
Newsday - August 16, 1990

The head of a defunct Brooklyn day-care center is accused of illegally obtaining $3,000 worth of food stamps, the Brooklyn District Attorney's office announced yesterday. 

Mordechai Ehrman, 49, of Brooklyn's Midwood section, surrendered to authorities yesterday and was charged with 13 counts that include grand larceny, filing false applications with the state Department of Social Service and falsifying false business records. 

He pleaded innocent to the charges at his arraignment before State Supreme Court Justice Michael Curci yesterday afternoon. In an unusual move, Curci ordered Ehrman held overnight without bail. Leonard Robertson, a spokesman for the district attorney's office, said that the judge had issued the order because of a delay in processing fingerprints. 

Ehrman faces 2 1/3 to 7 years in prison if convicted of the most serious charge of grand larceny. 

Ehrman, who operated the Simcha Play group at his home, is at the center of allegations that dozens of children were sexually molested at his facility. Brooklyn District Attorney Charles Hynes said he had "no comment" on the the five-month-old grand jury investigation. 

But Assemblyman Dov Hikind, a Brooklyn Democrat, said yesterday that he had been told that the grand jury had concluded its investigation. He said he was concerned that Ehrman has not been charged in that case.

___________________________________________________________________________________

FAIR USE NOTICE
Some of the information on The Awareness Center's web pages may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. 
 
We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.
For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml . If you wish to use copyrighted material from this update for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. 

___________________________________________________________________________________

 

Friday, February 16, 1990

Case of the Unnamed Jewish Quarter Child Molester

Case of the Unnamed Jewish Quarter child molester 

Jerusalem, Israel


Suspicions  in the quarter that the 16-year-old arrested by the police in 1988 had "taken the rap" for his older brothers, who are still on the loose. The youth was eventually institutionalized. This case involves a 5 year old male victim.
_________________________________________________________________________________

Disclaimer: Inclusion in this website does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement. Individuals must decide for themselves if the resources meet their own personal needs.

Table of Contents:

1990
  1. This Time, Police Get Residents' Cooperation - Jewish Quarter Child Molestation Incident Similar to 1988 Case (02/16/1990)
_________________________________________________________________________________

By Ron Kampeas
The Jerusalem Post - February 16, 1990

A recent sexual attack on a five-year-old boy in the Jewish Quarter bears similarities to a spate of incidents in 1988, with the difference that residents seem to be more inclined to cooperate with the police this time.

According to a resident of the quarter who requested anonymity, both cases involved knife-wielding men wearing kippot, and in both, members of the same family were said to be implicated by witnesses.

In the summer of 1988, however, police had difficulty obtaining evidence regarding the 16-year-old youth they had arrested. At the time, officials attributed the problem to the silence of a typically "close-knit" Orthodox community. The case was brought to public attention last week with the circulation of an English/Hebrew flyer published by the Jewish Quarter Residents' Committee.

The flyer quoted the Jewish Quarter's spiritual leader, Rabbi Avigdor Nebenzahl, as saying that "Halacha (Jewish law) demands that for the public good, information is forwarded, for the public good without limitation by the laws free of restraints of lashon hara (malicious gossip)."

It also asked parents to notify Dr. David Wilensky, a resident of the quarter, in case of further incidents and urged "increase watchful supervision over the children" following a recent sexual attack on a young boy.

This week the police spokesman said the case had been reported by the victim's family, and was under investigation. He said he could not confirm any description of the attacker.
Wilensky would not comment on the recent incident, insisting that publication would cause panic. He said, however, that the flyer had had the desired effect. The anonymous resident said there were suspicions in the quarter that the 16-year-old arrested by the police in 1988 had "taken the rap" for his older brothers, who are still on the loose. The youth was eventually institutionalized.

She said she understood that in the most recent case, the man had approached two children playing together in the early evening the Thursday before last. He drew a knife, and one of the two children ran away.

The parents of the child molested only discovered what had happened after the child suffered nightmares, she said.

_________________________________________________________________________________

FAIR USE NOTICE

Some of the information on The Awareness Center's web pages may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc.

We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml . If you wish to use copyrighted material from this update for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

_________________________________________________________________________________


"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has."–– Margaret Mead

_________________________________________________________________________________

Monday, December 04, 1989

Case of Rabbi Haim Pardes

Case of Rabbi Haim Pardes
(AKA: Chaim Pardes)
Rehov Frishman synagogue
Former President of the Tel Aviv Rabbinical Court - Tel Aviv Israel


Convicted of sexually blackmailing" and performing "licentious acts" with women who sought his counsel in a synagogue. Pardes was sentenced to six months in prison and given an 18-month suspended prison sentence and fined 25,000 shekels ($12,500).
___________________________________________________________________________________


Disclaimer: Inclusion in this website does not constitute a recommendation or endorsement. Individuals must decide for themselves if the resources meet their own personal needs.

Table of Contents:  

1989
  1. Rabbi Named in Sex-For-Divorce Scandal (12/04/1989)
  2. Police Interrogate Rabbinical Court Judges About Sex-Bribe Allegations  (12/05/1989)
  3. Police and Thieves  (12/15/1989)

1990
  1. D.A. Gets Sex-Case File Against TA Rabbi  (01/11/1990)
  2. Top Of The News - World  (12/07/1990)

1992
  1. Rabbi Starts 6 Months in Jail for Sex Abuse  (01/01/1992)
  2. Prosecutors Joins MK's Plea to Discipline Judge (05/23/1992)

2004
  1. Chief Rabbi of Ariel accused of rape (08/31/2004)

_______________________________________________________________________________

Rabbi Named In Sex-For-Divorce Scandal
by Andy Goldberg and Haim Shapiro
The Jerusalem Post - December 4, 1989


TEL AVIV - Rabbi Haim Pardes, head of the local rabbinical court, is facing a police investigation into suspicions that he asked a woman for sexual favour in order to speed up her divorce proceedings.

Police are still waiting for permission from Attorney-General Yosef Harish to interrogate Pardes, as Pardes has the legal standing of a district court judge. The initial finding of the police investigation were transferred to Harish's office late last week.

The national fraud squad has already interrogated people connected with the allegations against Pardes, including two senior clerks of the court and the woman he allegedly approached.

Police believe that Pardes had been dealing with the woman's divorce case for some seven years when he suggested to her that they meet alone in a room at a North Tel Aviv synagogue. In return he promised to speed up the courts' treatment of her divorce proceedings.

The woman apparently recorded her conversations with Pardes and afterwards used the tape to force him to accelerate treatment of her case and to blackmail him.

Rabbinical circles expressed shock over the allegations.

Rabbi Eli Ben-Dahan, director of the rabbinical courts, told The Jerusalem Post yesterday that no action would be taken against Pardes at this stage. It was not necessary to suspend a rabbinical court judge unless he had actually been charged with a crime, Ben-Dahan said.

According to the daily Yediot Ahronot, which first broke the story, Rabbi David Einhorn, assistant director of the Tel Aviv Rabbinical Court, was also suspected of accepting bribes.

 
_______________________________________________________________________________

Police Interrogate Rabbinical Court Judges About Sex-Bribe Allegations
By Andy Goldberg
The Jerusalem Post - December 5, 1989


The rabbinical court judge at the centre of a sex-for-divorce scandal was interrogated for seven hours yesterday by officers of the Jaffa-based National Fraud Division.

Rabbi Haim Pardess, 54, was released on his own recognizance after the interrogation and praised his investigators for "their fair and correct treatment."

The police are investigating allegations that Pardess solicited sexual favours from women in return for speeding up treatment of their divorce proceedings. One woman told officers last month that Pardess had been dealing with her divorce case for about seven years when he suggested that they meet alone in a room he had at his disposal at a local synagogue. In return for such a meeting, he promised to expedite the court's handling of her divorce. The woman apparently recorded her conversations with Pardess and afterwards used the tape to force him to expedite her case and to blackmail him for NIS 20,000.

Officers have already questioned several persons connected with the allegations against Pardess.

Pardess's attorney, Dr. Ya'acov Weinroth, told The Jerusalem Post that his client had cooperated fully with the police. He did not know whether Pardess would be summoned for further questioning. He said that the police did not have in their possession any tape recording that incriminated Pardess.

Rabbinical court judges have the legal standing of district court judges, whose interrogation is permitted only with the approval of the attorney-general. Yosef Harish granted this approval in Pardess's case on Sunday.

"I am very happy that I have had the opportunity to give my version of events and explode the baseless allegations against me," Pardess told Kol Yisrael radio after his interrogation.

He was highly critical of the press for publishing the story and his identity before he had been charged. He told reporters that he planned to continue working as usual despite the allegations and said he hoped that "with God's help the truth will out."
___________________________________________________________________________________

Police and Thieves 
Jerusalem Post - December 15, 1989

The police probe into suspected corruption at the Tel Aviv rabbinical court has not stopped at the sexual favours allegedly demanded by the court's chief, Rabbi Haim Pardes, in return for the speedy handling of divorce cases. In addition, the Jaffa-based Fraud Division is checking out suspicions that court clerks also accepted bribes related to cases.

To date, three women have lodged complaints against Pardes, two of them claiming that he sexually assaulted them after luring them into a room in a Rehov Frishman synagogue saying that he would expedite their divorce requests.

Police sources say the investigation has yielded indications of corruption on a far wider scale than initially believed, and that numerous court workers would be interrogated.

Details of a daring operation deep in Lebanon by officers of the elite Tel Aviv Central Unit were disclosed this week in a star-studded Mann Auditorium variety show celebrating the unit's 30th anniversary.

In late 1987, Eli Arazi, a top underworld figure, reported to police that he had been hired to transfer some two tons of hashish and heroin from Lebanon to Israel. Despite suspecting a hostage-taking trap by terrorists, detectives of the central unit and the anti-terror group manned the drug-running ship. The drugs were transferred to the ship near Jounieh and brought to Israel where they were transferred to four men who were meant to deliver them to the buyers. On the way from the port, however, the vehicle broke down. Police arrested the couriers but never caught up with the drug's buyers.

A drug-dealer was sentenced to seven years in jail by the Tel Aviv district court after one of his clients turned state's witness and tape-recorded two drug transactions. Every week, for some nine months, the dealer, Yoav Lavi, 29, of Bat Yam, supplied 30-50 grams of cocaine and heroin to a man named Shlomo. The cocaine cost $70 per gram and the heroin $250. When Shlomo was caught by police in possession of 30 grams of the drugs, he agreed to collect evidence in return for having the charges against him dropped.

Police outfitted him with a hidden microphone, and he recorded his next two meetings with Lavi. These recordings later formed the main part of the prosecution's case.


___________________________________________________________________________________

D.A. Gets Sex-Case File Against TA Rabbi
The Jerusalem Post - January 22, 1990



TEL AVIV - Police have transferred to the District Attorney's Office details of their investigation into complaints of sexual assault against Haim Pardes, the head rabbi of the Tel Aviv Rabbinical Court. The Jaffa-based National Fraud Division began investigating Pardes late last year after two women complained that he had promised to speed up treatment of their divorce cases in return for sexual favours.

In separate and unrelated complaints, the women charged that Pardes had invited them into a room in the Tel Aviv synagogue where he officiates and then indecently assaulted them. One woman claimed that Pardes had offered her NIS 20,000, if she did not report him to the police. Police investigators said that such an amount had been withdrawn from the rabbi's bank account.

Pardes continues to work as usual after having told police investigators in November that he had not committed the offences attributed to him. Pardes's status in the rabbinical court is equivalent to that of a district court judge and a decision to prosecute him can only be taken by order of the attorney general.

___________________________________________________________________________________

Top Of The News - World
From Wire Dispatches and Staff Reports


The Washington Times - December 7, 1990


TEL AVIV, Israel - A court jailed a senior rabbi for six months yesterday after finding him guilty of "sexually blackmailing" women who sought his counsel and of having sexual relations in a synagogue, court sources said.

Rabbi Haim Pardes, chief of Tel Aviv's rabbinical tribunal, committed "licentious acts" with women who appeared before him and he confessed to having sexual relations in a synagogue, according to the sources.

He was also given an 18-month suspended prison sentence and fined 25,000 shekels ($12,500) for "shamefully taking advantage of his judicial status and of the distress of the women who appeared before him." Rabbinical tribunals in Israel are charged with marital affairs and conversions to Judaism.

Shulat Aloni, a lawmaker for the Civil Rights Party, argued that the sentence against Rabbi Pardes was too lenient. Mrs. Aloni called for a review by the high court.

___________________________________________________________________________________

Rabbi Starts 6 Months in Jail for Sex Abuse
By Michael Rotem
The Jerusalem Post - January 1, 1991



TEL AVIV - The former chairman of the local rabbinical court convicted of sexually abusing women is to start his prison term today.

A court here rejected Rabbi Haim Pardes's offer to do community service work, instead of going to prison, as a part of a plea bargain.

Pardes was sentenced on December 6 by a district court here to imprisonment and fined after being convicted of committing obscene sexual acts, fraud and breach of trust.

The sentence was handed down after a plea bargain was accepted. In return for his confessing to having committed the obscene sexual acts, Pardes was sentenced to six months' imprisonment, an 18-month suspended sentence and a fine of NIS 25,000.

In its original verdict, the court decided that the rabbi would do community service.

The offer made by the special comissioner of community service to the court was that Pardes would work arranging and translating holy texts in a library for the blind. The judges, however, objected, saying that this work "was suitable for a high school student on vacation."

In one of the cases on which Pardes was convicted, he met with a mother of two daughters in his chamber to discuss her alimony claim. During one of their meetings, he sexually molested her.

A source in the Prison's Authority said yesterday there was no decision on where the rabbi would serve his term.
___________________________________________________________________________________

Prosecutors Joins MK's Plea to Discipline Judge
PROSECUTOR JOINS MK'S PLEA TO DISCIPLINE JUDGE

The Jerusalem Post - May 23, 1991


In an unusual move, the State Prosecutor's Office yesterday supported MK Yair Tsaban's petition asking the High Court of Justice to order that the pension of Rabbi Haim Pardes, president of the Tel Aviv Rabbinical Court sentenced to six months in prison for indecent acts, bribery and violating a trust, be stopped and that he be brought before a disciplinary hearing.

After the State Prosecution's move, the High Court issued an order nisi instructing Pardes to show within 30 days why the decision of the judicial appointments committee which awarded him a pension should not be overturned and why the president of the Supreme Rabbinical Court has not fulfilled his responsibility to bring him before a disciplinary hearing.

In his petition, Tsaban said that it was obvious that a judge convicted of such serious offenses should face a disciplinary hearing. Pardes, he noted, managed to avoid this by resigning his position when the charges were brought against him. He also maintained that he should not have been granted any pension, let alone the same one as judges who honorably retired from the bench.

_______________________________________________________________________________


Chief Rabbi of Ariel accused of rape
Maariv - Hebrew edition
August 31, 2004
http://www.nrg.co.il/online/1/ART/776/524.html


הרב נעצר בחשד שאנס אישה שהגיעה להתייעץ עמו, ואף הטריד אותה בשיחות טלפון

  טל ימין-וולבוביץ'
31/8/2004  10:54

הרב הראשי של אריאל נעצר הבוקר בחשד למעשה אונס באישה שהגיעה לבקש את עזרתו.

האישה, שנזקקה לעזרת הרב, הגיעה בתקופה האחרונה אל משרדו כדי להתייעץ איתו בנושא אישי. על-פי החשד, הרב ניצל את קרבתו לאישה ולאחר הייעוץ, אנס אותה בכוח. הוא לא הסתפק בכך, ואף הטריד אותה בטלפון לאחר המקרה. האישה, שלא יכלה לעמוד בהטרדות, נשברה והתלוננה במשטרה.

למרות התלונה, משטרת יהודה ושומרון לא יכלה לעצור בתחילה את הרב, מאחר שמדובר באישיות ציבורית. רק בהמשך, לאחר שהוצאו אישורים מיוחדים, פתחה המשטרה בחקירה סמויה שבסופה נעצר הרב בסמוך לביתו.

בשעות הצהריים יובא הרב להארכת מעצרו בבית משפט השלום בכפר-סבא. על כל פרטי החקירה הוטל צו איסור פרסום, ו-NRG מעריב הגיש בקשה לבית המשפט להסיר את הצו.

הרב שלמה עמאר, הרב הראשי הספרדי לישראל אמר: "כל זמן שאין שום הוכחה מוצקה, אנחנו בוחרים שלא להגיב".

לא מדובר במקרה ראשון של מעשה מגונה שמיוחס לרב. הרב זאב קופולוביץ, לשעבר ראש ישיבת "נתיב מאיר", הורשע על- פי הודאתו בהטרדות מיניות שביצע בתלמידיו. ונשלח בעיסקת טיעון לשלוש וחצי שנות מאסר.

בשנת 1999 נידון הרב חיים פרדס לשישה חודשי מאסר בפועל לאחר שהורשע בביצוע מעשים מגונים בנשים, מירמה והפרת אמונים.

--------------------------

Translated to English using Google Translate

Great city of Ariel suspected of rape

Rabbi arrested for allegedly raping a woman who came to consult him , and harassed her with phone calls


 Phone right - and Mabovich
31/08/2004 10:54


Chief Rabbi Ariel was arrested this morning on suspicion of raping a woman actually came to ask for his help.

The woman , who needed the aid of the rabbi, recently came to his office to consult him on the subject personally. The - allegedly used the proximity to great woman and consultation , raped her by force. Is not satisfied , and harassed her on the phone after the incident . The woman , who could not stand the harassment , broke down and complained to the police.

Despite the complaint, Judea and Samaria police could not stop the rabbi first , since it is a public personality . Only later , after the special permits issued , the police arrested an undercover investigation after which Rabbi near his home.

Afternoon will be great to extend his detention in the village magistrate - Grandpa. The details of the investigations imposed the gag order , and NRG Ma'ariv applied to the court to remove the order.

Rabbi Shlomo Amar , the Sephardic chief rabbi of Israel said : "As long as there is no solid proof , we choose not to respond."

This is not the first case of indecent acts attributed to Rabbi . Rabbi Zev Kopolovitz, former head of Yeshivat "Path Meir " , was convicted - though he admits sexual harassment committed by his students . And sent a plea bargain to three and a half years in prison.

In 1999, Rabbi Haim Pardes was sentenced to six months in prison after being convicted of molesting women , fraud and breach of trust.

Rabbis who go off the rails
By Rabbi Gideon Sylvester
Jewish Chronical (London) - July 6, 2006

Is it wrong to shop a straying rabbi to the authorities? And should he be treated as an outcast if he falls from grace? Rabbi Gideon Sylvester on how to cope with errant clerics

Rabbinical scandals are rare, but the religious world has been shaken in recent years by the conviction or impending trials of several high-profile rabbis on charges of sexual abuse. When a community learns that the person who taught them Torah, shared their joyous moments and comforted them through their crises stands accused of immoral conduct, they face difficult dilemmas.

Should they give credence to stories that could destroy his life or dismiss the accusations, risking further assaults and causing pain to those who came forward to report the misdemeanours? If the rabbi is found guilty, then the trauma for his followers is magnified as they find themselves re-evaluating every moment that he spent with them, sifting the genuine from the sham, and trying to understand what it means to have their spiritual leader exposed as a criminal.

Although the Talmud openly discusses the mishaps of rabbis who occasionally yielded to temptation, our sources reveal little precedent for recent falls from grace. The closest we come is the conduct of the first-century scholar, Rabbi Elisha ben Abuya — a brilliant man who became a bitter heretic and found horrific ways to vent his anger.

Once Elisha ben Abuya lost his faith, he would visit schools and disrupt lessons, using his charismatic personality to persuade pupils to abandon their studies and seek work elsewhere. On one trip, Elisha invited students to recite biblical verses. One by one, they related passages declaring that there was no hope for the wicked. For Elisha, these citations sent a clear, personal message; he could never repent and would never return to the fold. Frustrated by his situation and exasperated by the innocence of the children sitting before him, he knifed a young boy and carved his body into pieces.

While other versions of the story suggest that he only threatened, but did not carry out, these gruesome acts, the Jerusalem Talmud amplifies his guilt, stating that he murdered several promising students. Whichever version is correct, Elisha had become a cruel, manipulative man with a malign effect on the community.

Once they had dealt with the trial and punishment of Elisha, the rabbis faced a dilemma. Elisha ben Abuya had been their teacher and their inspiration. Now that he had been exposed as a dangerous criminal, how were they to view the Torah he had taught them? Should they discard all his ideas as the misguided thoughts of a dangerous heretic, or could something be salvaged from his teachings?

Sensitive to those who had based their faith on this man, the rabbis responded that the words of a scholar could be compared to a nut which fell in the mud: its shell was tarnished, but its contents uncontaminated. Though a scholar may sin, his Torah remained pristine.

At the same time, the rabbis issued clear instructions about choosing a teacher. Analysing a verse which describes a priest as an angel of the Lord, they advised: if your teacher is like an angel, then learn from him, but if he is not, then don't make him your mentor. Jewish study is not purely academic and we have a right to demand that our rabbis and teachers live according to the highest standards of morality and religious observance.

But if you think that your rabbi is up to mischief, is it right to report him to the police? The biblical command, "Do not to stand idly by your brother's blood" (Leviticus 19:16), means that, if we see someone who is being viciously attacked, we must use all possible means to save them (Talmud Sanhedrin 73a).

Rabbi Eliezer Waldenberg, a leading authority on the beth din of Jerusalem, wrote an extensive responsum on child abuse. Basing his opinion on this verse, he ruled that it would include our obligation to protect people from sexual abuse. Although historically, Jewish law was reticent about handing over Jewish criminals to the non-Jewish courts, where they might suffer injustice and antisemitism, in a country with a fair and effective judicial system, one must report all such crimes to the police.

Preserving human dignity and honouring scholars are important religious principles. But Jewish tradition is clear that even concern for the status of rabbis cannot override our duty to deal with outrages and shield the innocent. Where a crime is committed, religion is brought into disrepute: all concern for the honour of scholars must be put aside.

The story of Elisha ben Abuya reminds us that the Torah recognises human fallibility. Even biblical heroes and outstanding scholars are susceptible to temptation and to mental illness, which can twist and pervert their minds. No one is exempt from the dangers. That is why the rabbis warned all of us: "Do not be complacent about yourself until your dying day."

When there are indications that someone working for the community has succumbed to his worst instincts and poses a public danger, it is the duty of all who are aware to make appropriate inquiries and contact the authorities. This does not create a carte blanche for gossip, but it does mean we must do whatever necessary to ensure that potential victims are protected.

By dealing openly with the few cases of rogue rabbis, we can have confidence that the overwhelming majority of our teachers remain righteous, upstanding spokespeople of the Torah.


Roll of dishonour

n Rabbi Baruch Lanner, dynamic head of America's National Council of Synagogue Youth, was sentenced to seven years in 2002 for molesting girls in his school. He was initially released after five days, pending appeal, but was sent back to prison in 2005.

n Rabbi Mordechai (Marc) Gafni left the Bayit Chadash Synagogue in Tel Aviv this May in the wake of allegations by several women of sexual misconduct. He returned to the USA, admitting he had a "sickness."

n Rabbi Ze'ev Kopolevitch, principal of the prestigious Netiv Meir Yeshivah High School in Jerusalem, was jailed for three-and-a-half years in 1999 for molesting boys.

Gideon Sylvester is an adviser on diaspora affairs in the Israeli Prime Minister's Office


_______________________________________________________________________________


FAIR USE NOTICE

Some of the information on The Awareness Center's web pages may contain copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc.

We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

For more information go to: http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/17/107.shtml . If you wish to use copyrighted material from this update for purposes of your own that go beyond 'fair use', you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

_______________________________________________________________________________


"Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has." –– 
Margaret Mead

_______________________________________________________________________________